From Victim to Defendant: Race, Gender, and Survivor Criminalization in the Chrystul Kizer Case

Rhonelle Bruder, MSc, PhD(c) (she/her) & Cassandra Mary Frances Young, PhD (she/her) | September 25 | 9:45-10:45 am EDT

Topic: Legal | Knowledge Level: Intermediate

The criminalization of sex trafficking survivors, particularly Black girls, remains a persistent and under-examined form of structural injustice within anti-trafficking and the criminal legal system. This presentation draws on the recently published article “Justice Denied: Lessons from the Chrystul Kizer Case,” examining how misogynoir, adultification, and systemic racism shape responses to Black survivors of sex trafficking, often resulting in their treatment as offenders rather than victims. Using the Kizer case as a critical lens, the presenters explore how racialized gender stereotypes, poverty, and institutional failures intersect to deny Black girls recognition, protection, and justice. Although Kizer was trafficked as a minor and acted in self-defense against her trafficker, she was prosecuted and incarcerated, illustrating how legal frameworks frequently fail to account for the realities of coercion, exploitation, and survival responses. The case highlights broader patterns in which Black girls are hyper-sexualized, perceived as more culpable and less innocent, and excluded from victim-centered protections. This presentation situates Kizer’s experience within existing scholarship on trafficking, criminology, and intersectionality and identifies critical implications for public awareness, legal reform, professional training, and survivor-informed practice. The presenters argue that without explicitly addressing misogynoir and adultification bias, anti-trafficking and justice systems will continue to reproduce harm. The session concludes with concrete recommendations for re-imagining criminal legal responses to trafficking, emphasizing trauma-informed, culturally responsive, and survivor-led approaches that move beyond punishment toward equity, healing, and justice for Black survivors.

 

Presentation Objectives:

•  Examine how misogynoir and adultification contribute to the criminalization of Black sex trafficking survivors

•  Analyze the Chrystul Kizer case as a critical example of systemic failure within anti-trafficking and criminal legal responses

•  Apply intersectional frameworks to better understand survivor experiences at the intersection of race, gender, and victimization

•  Identify policy, legal, and practice-based strategies to reduce survivor criminalization and promote survivor-informed justice

About the Presenters