2024 Schedule
Wednesday, September 18, 2024
9:00 - 9:30
Morning Welcome
9:45 - 10:45
The intensity of climate migration across South Asia will undergo a triple multiplier effect by 2050. Climate change-related disasters are amplifying channels of human trafficking and the consequent illicit economy of exploitation, with a particular increase in Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG). India has been the epicenter of Trafficking in Persons across South Asia. This presentation questions how the double whammy of climate change and climate migration displacement can enmesh vulnerable stakeholders into a globalized illicit economic system within South Asia. Using desk-based secondary literature review of academic articles, news reports and grey literature from global and regional civil society publications, the study will be descriptive and qualitatively analyzed. In “Securitization Matrix in South Asia: Bangladeshi Migrants as an Enemy Alien”, Priyankar Upadhyaya elucidates how both forced and voluntary migration are ascending issues in the context of intra-regional demographic dynamics of South Asia, given the problematic cross-border flows of indigenous women being precariously positioned within the trafficking asymmetry of South Asia. One cannot categorize a preventive or anticipatory migration of a household due to the onset of a cascade of climate-disruptive events into a binary of voluntary and involuntary displacement. It reflects a reluctant dislocation, with the outer seemingness of willingness to undertake displacement. The nature of the classification of such migration is breaking binaries and thus can be called queering of studying climate disaster impacts. This particular lens must be applied to climate-related events in South Asia to consolidate changes in disaster management approaches in policy execution.
Presentation Objectives:
• Establish the human trafficking nexus at the regional level exacerbated by climate-related voluntary and involuntary migration
• Explore linkages between foreign policy objectives of the government in case of transnational displacement involved in human trafficking networks
• Underline the gendered-disproportionate consequences of climate crises and disasters leading up to and consolidating illicit flows of human trafficking
Many survivors of human trafficking are parents who face unique needs and real challenges in dealing with child welfare and family court after exiting their trafficking situation due to the stigma and misunderstanding of their trafficking experiences that survivors face in these systems. In Polaris’s First National Survivor Study, sex and labor trafficking survivors participated in focus groups, interviews, and a final survey with 457 participants. In their analysis, the researchers looked at the unique needs of parenting survivors and their considerably higher service needs, notably in childcare, education, job training, and mental health services. The findings underscore the necessity for comprehensive support systems and policy reform to facilitate their recovery and safeguard their children’s welfare. Survivors made it clear that their children and maintaining custody of them were chief among their concerns, and many detailed disputes they had faced in keeping their children with them. In particular, custody disputes with child welfare and with their exploiters are exhausting and traumatizing. Traffickers have used the court system and custody disputes to discredit survivors of trafficking and as a result, the justice system is being exploited to further victimize survivors. This study is one of the first to highlight the need that survivors have reported themselves on issues with custody and to look at the unique needs parenting survivors face after exit. Attendees will learn how to effectively engage with survivor parents and to advocate for their needs in various anti-trafficking settings.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the effect of systems on parenting survivors’ access to childcare, housing, education, and employment
• Explain the needs of survivors as related to children after leaving exploitation experience
• Discuss ways to address this issue including in support systems for survivors and policy reform
This presentation explores how the tool of narrative can be used to raise awareness, foster empathy, and ultimately combat human trafficking. When the author began her novel writing journey, she didn’t know how close to home the massively far-reaching and complex world of human trafficking lurked. What she learned about human trafficking enraged her, devastated her, and confused her. How could this nightmare scenario be a reality for so many? How could she know so little about it? She was at a crossroads: leave the story to someone else, or get involved in the fight against trafficking. Thanks to the shared stories of survivors, caregivers, and law enforcement, she began her journey of writing a story not her own in order to share the stories of many. Fiction offers a platform to amplify the often-unheard voices of the marginalized and vulnerable. Using storytelling as an advocacy tool opens the door to the world of human trafficking for an otherwise immobilized audience to join the fight happening just out of sight. Those wanting to learn more can become familiar with the crime and the impact on society, the economy, and the human race through “fictional” characters with common origins.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explore the journey from uninformed, inspired, exploring, to advocate
• Highlight how empathy can be used to bridge the gap between survivors and audience through storytelling
• Discuss the potential of fiction to inspire connection and action
• Explore real-world interventionists using storytelling as an aid in their fight against trafficking
• Provide resources to help move one from exploring to advocacy
At last year’s IHTSJ Conference, a group of Kenyan Survivor Advocates shared insights about becoming and being survivor advocates. One year later, the counter-trafficking movement in Kenya is noticeably changing. Survivor advocates and leaders are building their own networks. More organizations cooperate with survivor leaders and advocates in a systematic way, putting survivor advocates at the center in community, media, internal, and political engagements. All presenters are volunteer members of the HAART Survivor Advocates Group and/or the HAART Survivor Advisory Board; the presentation draws from their experiences on that journey. The HAART Survivor Advisory Board built on previous programs for survivor advocates and took it one step further, systematically including experts with lived experience in organizational procedures, external interactions, and program designs. Other organizations have formed committees, and survivor networks receive more attention from donors. Yet, a lot more remains to be done. Based on their personal experiences and gained expertise, the presenters want to encourage fellow survivors to join the counter trafficking movement. They wish to share with them and other stakeholders the variety of survivor engagement that goes far beyond sharing of personal experiences. On an institutional level, they will give recommendations for counter trafficking organizations, donors, and academia on how to achieve more systematic inclusivity of experts with lived experience.
Presentation Objectives:
• Promote more survivor inclusion and engagement
• Show the impact of being an empowered survivor advocate/leader
• Provide recommendations stakeholders on how to practically aim at more meaningful survivor inclusion
• Give others the opportunity to get to know survivor leaders and advocates better
Human trafficking, a $140 billion global industry, preys on marginalized persons, treating them as commodities. Global Slavery Index estimates that 49.6 million people are in modern slavery, with 6.3 million (23%) trapped in sex trafficking, predominantly women from low socio-economic backgrounds. Drugs and sex trafficking are two complex forms of crimes, forming a complex criminal web that exploits vulnerable lives, with drugs coercing victims into transactional sex, fostering a cyclical relationship. This presentation delves into intricate methodological challenges in researching these crimes, drawing upon ongoing empirical research undertaken by a PhD scholar at TISS in Mumbai, India. Employing an exploratory qualitative design approach, the study utilizes in-depth interviews and unstructured focus group discussions to explore relationship between drug use and sex trafficking and subsequent victimization by involving diverse adult participants through purposive and snowball sampling including trafficked victims, offenders, caregivers, drug and law enforcement officials, and NGO/people servicing centers at exploitation sites. It delineates methodological challenges inherent in researching the concurrent complexities associated with drugs and sex trafficking. Challenges encompass ethical considerations; securing government permissions to access custodial settings; surmounting barriers to gain entry to victims through gatekeepers; and addressing participant’s fear, reluctance, reservations, and denial to engage in the study and hesitancy regarding interview recordings due to terminologies associating drugs and sex. Researcher’s struggles included establishing trust, reflexivity, navigating feelings of isolation, and negotiating complex systems for data collection. Field experience emphasize the importance of innovative research methods for sensitive topics, particularly in amplifying the voices of hard-to-reach populations.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain how field learnings and personal experiences are instrumental in shaping this research topic.
• Explain the context of the study, significance, and concept used in the study
• Discuss the importance of methods in researching sensitive topics.
• Synthesize the insights from the field (i.e., “what is field teaching her as a researcher”)
This presentation will begin with defining sex and labor trafficking according to federal and state laws. Legislation related to the age of the human trafficking survivor will be reviewed as well as the obligations of mandated reporters. The Action, Means, Purpose Model will be shared along with details of who is recruiting trafficking survivors. Red flags and indicators of sex and labor trafficking will be discussed as well as how and where these types of trafficking can occur. Recruiters, customers, and traffickers and their roles “in the game” will be shared along with myths regarding “anybody can be trafficked.” Grooming practices will be shared along with a discussion of Stockholm syndrome. Myths will be reviewed about what is considered sex trafficking, labor trafficking, or both. The National Human Trafficking Hotline will be featured throughout the presentation. The presenter will define familial trafficking and who plays important roles in this type of trafficking. Online trafficking and protecting youth online will be discussed. Different types of apps, games, social media sites, the age of survivors, and their role in being trafficked will be reviewed as well as things parents can do to protect their youth from traffickers. Attendees will learn the basics regarding human trafficking and the importance traffickers place on building a relationship with their victims. Attendees will be able to go back to their communities and ensure that others receive training and can identify survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview of human trafficking focusing on sex and labor trafficking
• Describe signs of trafficking and the indicators of trafficking
• Explain why victims might not seek help and how everyone can join in anti-human trafficking efforts
Amidst the collective efforts to combat human trafficking, this presentation seeks to introduce a fresh perspective aimed at reducing the vulnerability of individuals to becoming traffickers. The concept of vulnerability has been applied to people who become victims of human trafficking, but rarely to the people who perpetrate the abuse, exploitation, and coercion that constitute human trafficking. Grounded in the acknowledgment of the complexity of the issue and the need for innovative approaches, this presentation develops an approach to identifying the underlying factors that drive individuals to perpetrate trafficking. Understanding that motivational ecology enables us to develop more effective prevention strategies. The anti-trafficking movement needs a paradigm shift towards perpetrator-focused interventions, emphasizing the importance of addressing both external and internal factors that contribute to perpetrator vulnerability. This presentation proposes what those key external and internal factors might be. Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs helps us understand how unmet physiological and safety needs contribute to vulnerability. Insights from the Global Slavery Index and an examination of vulnerabilities such as poverty and marginalization, highlight the interconnectedness of systemic and individual factors. The presentation calls for a holistic approach to combating human trafficking that integrates perpetrator-focused components into existing anti-trafficking efforts. By recognizing and addressing the vulnerabilities that lead individuals to become traffickers, we can more effectively prevent trafficking and protect vulnerable populations.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the various uses of the term "vulnerability" in the context of human trafficking
• Apply the notion of vulnerability to the people who abuse, exploit, and coerce
• Propose a range of internal and external factors that contribute to the motivational ecology of human trafficking perpetrators
• Suggest interventions that could reduce such vulnerability
Human trafficking remains a global issue, often overlooked due to misconceptions and biases. Among the marginalized victims, male trafficking victims and survivors face unique challenges, including legal and police biases and societal stigmatization. This presentation aims to shed light on the legal and law enforcement biases against male victims of human trafficking, propose strategies for building an intersectional legal and police response, and discuss best practices, challenges, and lessons learned in working with law enforcement and the legal system. Addressing legal and law enforcement biases against male victims of human trafficking in order to build an intersectional response require concerted efforts from policymakers, legal professionals, law enforcement agencies, and civil society. By adopting inclusive approaches, fostering collaborative partnerships, and prioritizing survivor-centered practices, we can enhance the legal protection and the frontline support available to male trafficking victims and survivors, ultimately contributing to a more just and equitable society.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss building an intersectional legal and police response
• Explain how an effective response to male trafficking necessitates an intersectional approach that acknowledges the diverse identities and experiences of victims
• Discuss intersecting factors such as gender, race, sexual orientation, and socioeconomic status that influence vulnerability to trafficking and access to legal remedies
Learn how Worthwhile Wear, a 501(c)(3) non-profit, has developed a platform fostering opportunities for partnerships among federal and local law enforcement, government, and social service providers to help break down the many barriers that exist between survivors of trafficking and the public sector. Worthwhile Wear’s ground-breaking “Worth It” initiative is a broad-reaching community-facilitated outreach program that invites survivors to participate in multidisciplinary educational sessions. “Worth It” utilizes an evidenced-based approach that addresses the most common underlying cause for recidivism, unresolved trauma. Trauma is the primary underlying factor that causes or perpetuates many societal issues like addiction, unemployment, fractured relationships, and maladaptive behaviors. When engaging with survivors enrolled in the “Worth It” program, Worthwhile Wear practices a three-stage model of trauma recovery as developed by Judith Herman’s extensive work in the field. Utilizing this methodology and employing evidence-based treatments such as TF-CBT, our therapist helps survivors establish coping skills and capacity to recognize their emotional state for self-regulation. Pre and post program data indicates participants' self-realization related to the exploitation that they have encountered and re-directs their framework from self-blame to survivorship. Attendees of this presentation will learn how survivors benefit most when public and private agencies work collaboratively, and how key healing factors aren’t reliant on good programming, but more so on trauma identification and developing healthy community relationships. This engaging presentation will have you laughing, learning, and considering how your organization can achieve a greater impact when serving survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain how to engage with survivors of trafficking to know what unique needs and challenges survivors of this crime have
• Discuss the importance of pursuing a proven method and utilizing the private sector to build/rebuild a healthy bridge to exploited individuals
11:15 - 12:15
This study examined the gap between the needs of trafficking victims in Zimbabwe and the country's National Plan of Action to Combat Trafficking in Persons 2023-2028 (NAPLAC) (re)integration strategy. This research employed a qualitative approach, focusing on in-depth interviews with key informants. To ensure reach to the most relevant participants, it used purposive sampling and a snowballing technique due to the sensitive nature of the topic to identify critical issues and needs largely unaddressed by NAPLAC’s superficial provisions. The research complemented the primary data by conducting document reviews of international and regional guidelines, policy frameworks and laws which will include the National Plan of Action 2023-2028, Trafficking in Persons Act, IOM Guideline for Assisting Victims of Trafficking, and Oxfam Good Practices on (Re)Integration of Victims of Trafficking. Findings highlighted the importance of a victim-centered approach recognizing unique experiences and vulnerabilities. Comprehensive support services are needed encompassing housing, healthcare, psychosocial support, education, vocational training, and livelihood opportunities. Targeted interventions to enhance economic empowerment and sustainable livelihoods were recommended. Regular needs assessments and incorporation of victim voices into reintegration strategies were also suggested. Strengthening legal frameworks consistent with international standards along with accessible services tailored to individual needs were identified as crucial. Addressing socio-economic contributing factors and implementing recommended measures will empower victims and facilitate successful (re)integration.
Presentation Objectives:
• Present a critical analysis of the gap between the needs of trafficking victims in Zimbabwe and the reintegration strategy outlined in NAPLAC 2023-2028
• Identify crucial needs of victims that are currently not adequately addressed by NAPLAC's provisions
• Emphasize the importance of a victim-centered approach to reintegration, recognizing the unique experiences and vulnerabilities of each victim
• Propose a framework for comprehensive support services encompassing housing, healthcare, psychosocial support, education, vocational training, livelihood opportunities, and economic empowerment initiatives
This presentation will help attendees understand the role of drugs and alcohol in the abduction and trafficking of missing and murdered Native Americans. Overall, 1.5 million Native American women have experienced violence in their lifetime. Indigenous people in the United States have rates of murder, rape, and violent crime higher than any other group. Indigenous women make up a significant portion of missing, murdered, and trafficked individuals. In many cases, alcohol and drug misuse, or the deliberate use of incapacitating substances by traffickers to aid abduction and compliance with abusers. Attendees will learn to recognize signs of trafficking, the prevalence of trafficking among missing and murdered indigenous persons in the United States and Canada, the identity and methods of traffickers, the role of substance misuse, and trauma-informed counseling strategies to aid survivors in recovery.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss dangers indigenous clients may be exposed to in terms of trafficking
• Describe the significant types of trafficking and MMIP in their area
• Identify the role forced and voluntary substance use plays in trafficking
The London Abused Women’s Centre and Salvation Army Correctional Justice Services in London, Ontario, Canada have partnered with the tertiary care facility, London Health Sciences Centre, London, Canada, to deliver tailored training to medical residents, as well as specialty-specific training to pediatrics, obstetrics/gynecology, emergency department, and psychiatry. Other providers present include nurses and social workers who may come in to contact with a victim of human trafficking. Research shows that a victim’s first point of supportive contact is often through a health agency. Through CARES (Consortium of Anti Human Trafficking Research and Education), this model demonstrates the importance of using a wraparound approach to leverage the skills, knowledge, and abilities in each respective profession to be able to identify signs of human trafficking and to know how to intervene. The CARE team trains front line workers on how to be aware of the signs of trafficking, how to respond, who to report to, and how to manage vicarious trauma. The team relies on both front-line workers and lived experience experts to inform the process and to ensure the community is knowledgeable of, and responsive to, the growing plague of human trafficking. The call to action of the CARE team is to inform and educate every sector that may come into contact with a victim of human trafficking with the goal of prevention and early intervention. Attendees will understand the benefit of a cross-sectoral collaborative approach to networking, educating, and training about human trafficking for front line workers in medical and other human service industries.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the importance of educating health professionals and other first responders
• Discuss risks and challenges for victims of sex trafficking who seek service, and what front line service providers need to know
• Discuss wraparound service model to meet the needs of victims of sex trafficking
Since the COVID-19 pandemic, there has been a concerning rise in human trafficking cases involving online forced criminal activity resulting in dual victimization. The extent of criminal activity, thousands of human trafficking victims, and the number of countries where such operations have occurred are a cause for concern and necessitates increased regional and international action. The breadth and depth of such criminal activities are enabled by criminal networks’ exploitation of the pandemic, job losses, the culture of migrant work specifically in the Southeast Asia region, and the ease of conducting illegal activity in Special Economic Zones (SEZs). The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) has passed a number of Conventions and Declarations to address the issue and follow-through has begun with implementation in various countries, but there is still much to do. The severity of the situation requires strengthening efforts at an international level including the financial and technology sectors to increase safety online and cooperate for the arrest and prosecution of the perpetrators. An effective response requires the cooperation of various governments, regional and international efforts beyond Southeast Asia which include the financial and technology sectors to extend assistance and prosecute such criminal networks. This means having comprehensive efforts targeting both physical and online spaces as a better response for human trafficking prevention, protection and prosecution, effectively addressing not just sex trafficking but also labor trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss new risk factors of human trafficking
• Describe ways to strengthen efforts to address this new type of human trafficking
• Facilitate discussion on possible policy actions or measures that can be done from their states/locations
The presenter will use both personal experience and professional expertise to shed light on a subject that demands our attention. It’s precisely because of her journey that she will stir up a whirlwind of emotions, showing why it’s crucial to lean into those feelings. That is where change begins and where the harsh realities of why this happens to regular, everyday people become apparent. As a mother of a trafficking survivor, Lynda realized she missed three crucial elements and will share them in this presentation, not to dwell on past mistakes but to illuminate the blind spots we all might have and to learn from them to prevent similar tragedies. The primary part of her presentation will be unveiling domestic sex trafficking and abuse. Fueled by cinematic portrayals like ‘Taken’ or ‘Sound of Freedom,’ international sex trafficking captures headlines, while domestic sex trafficking often hides in plain sight. Once oblivious to the possibility of such horrors befalling her children, Lynda aims to debunk common misconceptions surrounding domestic sex trafficking, shedding light on how seemingly normal relationships can cancel trafficking dynamics. During the presentation, attendees will gain insight into: 1) the true identities of traffickers compared to the cinematic stereotypes, 2) the demographics targeted by the trafficker and their underlying motivations, 3) vulnerabilities exploited by traffickers and who manipulate them to control the victim, 4) subtle indicators of trafficking, empowering attendees to recognize potential trafficking situations effectively, and 5) how individuals who have endured trafficking often perceive themselves as having consented to their exploitation. Lynda will outline the four essential criteria to address this misconception of consent, giving relatable examples.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain how our belief in what we thought sex trafficking looked like was the cause of the presenter’s daughter being a victim
• Discuss what the presenter learned about who the traffickers are
• Explain the differences between international and domestic sex trafficking
• Describe how the presenter has moved on by turning her pain into purpose by educating others on prevention
Initiatives such as “End Demand” oversimplify the multifaceted experiences of those involved in the sex trade. Rather than acknowledge the unique realities people have lived, the response is often to funnel them into the “Viminal Space.” This is a paradigm of state-imposed marginalization, situated between victimhood and criminality. Such black-and-white categories fail to recognize the diverse intersectionality within the sex-working communities, particularly among those from 2SLGBTQIA+ and BIPOC backgrounds. By over-policing individual livelihoods or trying to “save” people for their own good, “End Demand” fails to recognize victimization as it occurs in real-time. The presenters will speak to the limitations of initiatives such as “End Demand”. Outdated programs of this caliber have failed at meeting the complexity of individual needs for holistic recovery. They advocate for nuanced strategies that offer comprehensive support and viable pathways forward. In doing so, the presenters recognize and honor the diverse experiences of everyone involved in the sex trade. Attendees will gain a deeper understanding of the intersectionalities within sex work, as well as an awareness of the negative consequences that over-policing and rescue have on the well-being of citizens. As a call to action, the presenters advocate for policies and initiatives that integrate nuanced responses. Programs should honor the dignity, worth, and autonomy of the individuals they are representing. The presenters are committed to collaborations that provide comprehensive resources and support for individuals involved in or exiting the sex trade. Through education, they hope to inspire others to advocate for unbiased support and comprehensive resources for a brighter future.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide a basic overview of the four models of criminalization
• Discuss why it is crucial to study the effects of the “End Demand” initiative on vulnerable populations within the context of complex social issues
• Explain the economic theory of supply and demand as it applies to sex workers and trafficked individuals
• Define and evaluate the importance of addressing the root causes of trafficking
Since the early 2000s, there has been a growing focus on human trafficking, with scholars, advocates, policy makers, and survivors increasingly contributing to the narrative. The International Human Trafficking & Social Justice Conference has encapsulated two decades of national and global discussions on human trafficking and social justice issues. For this presentation, conference abstracts from 2004 to 2023 were analyzed using thematic analysis. The researchers reviewed and coded each abstract. Using inter-coder reliability, differences were resolved through discussion to establish consensus. Themes were developed inductively as they emerged from the abstracts. The two presenters would like to thank Anna Schramm for her contribution to the analysis of conference data and findings. This presentation sheds light on those enduring narratives, the evolving discourse on intersectionality, and the changing landscape of national and international dialogues surrounding human trafficking. It prompts reflection on our collective learnings and encourages deliberation on the future trajectory of the international conversation in this crucial area.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the trends and shifts in the narrative on human trafficking
• Synthesize the lessons learned and identify gaps for the future years
Ethical survivor engagement is a necessity in the fight against human trafficking, be it in serving the sector as an advocate or in any other capacity that involves what constitutes “work” within the setting of prevention, intervention, or aftercare. Survivor voices are needed to expand community knowledge and to maintain accountability. In this presentation, attendees will hear from two survivors who will be sharing their experiences working in the anti-trafficking field; where they see strengths and where they see room to grow within the sector. Drawing from their experiences and observations, they will walk through some common pitfalls and ways that organizations can avoid these so that survivors can be strengthened by their time working in this space, instead of feeling re-exploited. This session will specifically highlight the ethics surrounding organizational preparedness, compensation, and the ongoing professional development of survivors. With a combined professional background of over 15 years in the anti-trafficking and domestic violence sphere, their experiences will illustrate progress that has been made and setbacks that have been experienced. Survivors help to create organizational resilience when they are empowered to use their voice in an ethical way. With a focus on shared accountability that educates and empowers organizations, attendees will leave this session better equipped for working and engaging with survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss how ethical survivor engagement leads to organizational resilience
• Discuss deficits and where there is opportunity for growth within various areas of the sector
• Inspire survivors that their professional development is essential to the health of this space
Survivors of sex trafficking are resilient individuals capable of employing strategies when needed to manage situations of marginalization and oppression such as gender oppression, racism, and poverty. Nonetheless, trafficking-related research and services has most focused on risks, deficits, and vulnerabilities. This leaves researchers and practitioners with little knowledge for understanding and supporting survivors’ preferred resilience strategies. In this presentation, the researcher answers the question, “How do survivors manifest and maintain resilience?” through a participatory constructivist grounded theory method (Charmaz, 2014) where participants engaged in data interpretation. Data comprised 75 in-depth interviews with 44 other survivors of sex trafficking, and was analyzed with a community co-analyst. Findings showed that the core of resilience was the ability to make preferred choices amidst very limited options that: (1) brought participants closer to goals, (2) did not move them further away, or (3) moved them away as little as possible so they could recover as quickly as possible when there was an opportunity. Choices were facilitated by four elements: hope, purpose, values, and assets. These elements revealed how participants’ personal agency interacted with structural inequalities, foregrounding personal power, and implicating social services and other sectors in their experiences of risk and opportunity. Participants noted they needed the most support for making choices during the period immediately after trafficking. Participants recommended that this resilience knowledge be used to create training materials, self-help materials, and a resilience-enhancing app. The presentation concludes with recommendations for community-engaged, participatory research for improving resilience-enhancing services for survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the study and highlight the importance of acknowledging survivors’ resilience strategies and supporting and partnering with these strategies
• Describe survivors’ strategies, (i.e., how they use hope, values, purpose, and assets) to navigate situations of constrained choices amidst structural inequities
• Discuss implications and recommendations for integrating this into practice
12:30 - 1:30
Lunch Networking Sessions
1:45 - 2:45
Peel Region, Ontario is the second-largest municipality in the Greater Toronto Area. It’s located in Canada's largest economic area, borders the United States, has an airport, and has 5 major highways passing through. Peel continues to be a hot spot for sexual exploitation and is facing various economic crises, which have increased risks and vulnerabilities in its community. Housing continues to be a crisis, which adds to the challenges and increases risk and vulnerabilities for youth experiencing homelessness. Recognizing and understanding the intersectionality of youth homelessness and sexual exploitation, participants will take away a comprehensive understanding of the keys to providing intervention and establishing prevention for exploitation within youth shelters. Through operating Peel’s youth shelters and nCourage (Peel’s Anti-Human Trafficking Integrated Service Hub), Our Place Peel will shed light on the reality, risks, and vulnerabilities when youth experience homelessness. Youth continue to be an overrepresented group in homelessness and exploitation. The presenter will explore policies, interventions, and practices that support young people through their journey to healing and housing. Attendees will take with them the importance of community collaboration, client-centered/led work, and advocacy for systems change.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an understanding of the intersectionality of youth homelessness and sexual exploitation
• Discuss examples of intervention and prevention strategies and community collaborations to help support youth experiencing homelessness and sexual exploitation
• Explain how to increase access to dedicated support and services for youth experiencing homelessness who are at risk of or identify as victims/survivors
• Increase collaboration, coordination, and evidence-based practice across the system responding to human sex trafficking with the youth population
Children and young people voraciously consume technology and social media, expanding social connections and relationships far beyond previous generations. With such advances, it has been argued, young people are at greater risk of exposure to unwanted sexual material and advances via these media. Some youth appear to be particularly vulnerable to internet solicitation, placing them at significant risk of subsequent sexual victimization. This presentation is an extension of last year’s discussion at the IHTSJ Conference. It will serve to review basic theory and how early disruptions in attachment and developmental needs contribute to vulnerability to internet solicitation and sexual exploitation and trafficking. Using this information as a springboard, the discussion will highlight various avenues of improving prevention, detection, and intervention, ranging from parent education, to provider education, to greater system involvement and program development.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explore how attachment and development may contribute to specific vulnerabilities to online grooming and solicitation
• Discuss various applications of theory in improving prevention, detection and intervention
This presentation will outline the ups and downs in a decade long investigation into one of the biggest human traffickers in Dallas, Texas: Macc Bucc. This presentation will dive into the lives of those trafficked and the remaining scars that are still evident in their lives. This presentation will also show the loyalty that human trafficking victims have towards their trafficker. Detectives will show the different methods used to build evidence in this case that covered multiple jurisdictions. Attendees will see how other investigative techniques can be used to collect evidence and the small part it plays in the “big picture.” Attendees will see how perseverance in an investigation led to a greater outcome that benefits the public even more so than law enforcement. Attendees can use this case study as a means for successful investigations in the field of human trafficking. As human trafficking becomes an even bigger focus for law enforcement and the community, this session will show detectives the work involved in these types of prosecutions.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the loyalty of trafficking victims and why they "choose" the life
• Describe the different investigative techniques when faced with these type of investigations
• Explain how thinking outside the investigative box and patience can pay off in the end
One would think that human trafficking victims are mostly kidnapped against their will by very powerful trafficking rings. However, this is not the case in a Southern Nigerian state known as Edo State. Majority of the sex trafficking victims in West Africa hail from this part of the country. Parents plead with traffickers to sponsor their daughters abroad to “hustle” as early as 16 years of age. What would make a parent consent to the trafficking of his or her own offspring? They claim they want the family to have a better financial life and to escape the harsh realities of a country where most youths are unemployed and majority of the population live below poverty level. The major push factor of sex trafficking in Africa has always been poverty. Victims, as well as parents, consent to their own trafficking in that part of the world. The victims even willingly participate in oath ceremonies orchestrated by traffickers through voodoo priests. This presentation will discuss the legal implication of a victim's consent to being trafficked (e.g., Does a victim's consent reduce a trafficker's culpability?). This presentation will conclude with initiatives and recommendations to the government of Africa as well as NGOs on how to curb this menace especially through providing a better economy for its people and through education.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the legal implication of a victim's consent to being trafficked
• Explain how most West African sex trafficking victims' parents recruit their own daughters into trafficking.
• Provide insight into the role of poverty as a push factor of sex trafficking in Africa
• Provide recommendations for prevention
Through the lens of complex trauma and posttraumatic growth, this workshop will share findings from a qualitative study focused on the impact and experiences of sex trafficking survivors. This study included in-depth interviews and photovoice methods and followed principles of trauma-informed research with 15 adult survivors who were all trafficked within the United States and had been separated from the trafficker for minimum one year. Using purposive convenience selection with snowball sampling, it answered the following research questions: What are the experiences of adult female domestic sex trafficking survivors? How do women view these experiences as influencing identity, sexuality, relationships, and seeking services after separation from trafficker? What factors do survivors believe contribute to community reintegration? Through rich data from interviews and photovoice captioned images, workshop participants will hear and see direct evidence of the aspects of complex trauma as well as the capacity for posttraumatic growth. This presentation will specifically emphasize the power of “bearing witness” to another’s pain through empathic listening and witness, as a mutual benefit for transforming traumatic experiences, and thus serving as a catalyst for societal change. Participants will listen to the voices and impact of sex trafficking through photography taken by survivors and practice having our listening inform our response. Finally, workshop participants will receive recommendations directly from the voices of survivors on what factors help or hinder community reintegration and posttraumatic growth. Key findings that will be explored include avoiding re-traumatization and re-exploitation and the integral role of relationship in the reintegration process for survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Define the practice of bearing witness to complex trauma and posttraumatic growth and how it is observed in victims of domestic sex trafficking
• Provide recommendations for post-trafficking community reintegration that come directly from survivors of sex trafficking
The world is harder for girls than it has ever been. Data released in 2023 from the CDC revealed that nearly 60% of high school girls reported feeling persistently sad or hopeless, 30% have seriously considered suicide, and 20% experienced sexual violence. While these statistics are alarming, there is increased concern when taken into consideration with vulnerabilities associated with exploitation. Research shows that when girls have low self-confidence, decreased connection and support, and lack of access to accurate information, they are at an increased risk for exploitation. The CDC findings are a signal that precise attention be paid to the health, safety, education, and empowerment of girls. Calls for programs, interventions, and efforts that increase girls’ connection to school, sense of belonging, and coping skills have made clear the necessity of programs and organizations like Ruling Our eXperiences, Inc. (ROX). ROX is the national leader in programming, research, and education focused on girls. Their mission is to create generations of confident girls who control their own relationships, experiences, decisions, and futures. ROX uses the best practices in research to implement evidence-based empowerment programming in schools, conduct large-scale national research, and educate the community on the issues impacting girls. This presentation will highlight the ROX 20-week evidence-based program which is delivered in schools across 33 states with girls in grades 5-12. Attendees will gain an understanding of the skills, competencies, and support needed to reduce vulnerabilities and will leave with specific strategies for protecting and empowering girls.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss risk factors for exploitation of girls
• Describe the skills, competencies, and supports necessary for reducing girls’ vulnerabilities
• Provide specific strategies for empowering and supporting girls
Attendees will learn the importance of shared language, building relationships, and fostering trust. They will gain knowledge about a collaborative communication approach that encourages input from victims and survivors to build safety and trust in relationships. By learning to communicate with commonly accepted terms across disciplines, attendees can adapt language that reduces stigma and bias to overcome barriers. They will also gain insight into advancing individual-centered outreach and support services through civic engagement, non-government, and government partnerships while combatting human trafficking at the local, state, and federal levels. Carolyn Kinkoph will explain how the victimization of her daughter, Courtney, and ongoing advocacy efforts as a co-founder of the Alliance Against Human Trafficking (AAHT) highlight the need to utilize meaningful shared language and individual-centered strategies that support victims of human trafficking without stigmatizing, revictimizing, and retraumatizing them. Carolyn’s experience, ability to collaborate, and education provide insight into various anti-trafficking strategies for human trafficking prevention from human rights, criminal justice, social justice, and healthcare perspectives. The complexities and intersections of human trafficking along with the failure of several systems drive Carolyn’s determination to command change. She will share how encounters with providers, law enforcement agencies, survivors, and professionals in several disciplines further her ability to educate and partner with others. Attendees will learn about the importance of utilizing a proactive approach to break silos, coordinate efforts within and across systems, build multidisciplinary teams, and use shared language to promote trauma-responsive comprehensive care for victims and survivors of human trafficking, exploitation, and abuse.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the role of language relative to the victimization of individuals and interactions with others from different perspectives
• Explain how to apply what individuals learn from experiences and the importance of using shared language
• Describe the various resources that have the ability to assist a victim of trafficking using trauma-informed, individual-centered strategies
In this presentation, Jarrett Davis and Wendy Stiver explore the ethical application of artificial intelligence (AI) to enhance survivor-led research. The presentation begins by providing an overview of the critical ethical issues related to AI that must be addressed to responsibly incorporate this technology into research and society. Best-case and worst-case scenarios, likely outcomes, and necessary policies and processes to proactively address potential risks while harnessing AI's benefits are examined. The focus then shifts to practical applications of AI to enhance survivor-led research, particularly in qualitative data analysis. Using sample interviews, Davis and Stiver demonstrate how AI-powered thematic analysis tools can efficiently synthesize qualitative data while allowing for human verification and triangulation. This approach has immense potential to empower survivors to shape research and uncover impactful insights without the typical barriers in qualitative work. Attendees will gain an understanding of key ethical considerations in practical knowledge of leveraging AI to enhance qualitative research and inspiration for thoughtfully harnessing new technology for social good in a survivor-centered way. The accessible live demonstration aims to spark ideas for responsibly integrating AI into attendees' own work supporting and empowering survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview of key ethical considerations in applying AI to survivor-led research
• Summarize currently available models and their differing approaches and applications, along with limitations applied to survivor and community led research in the development field
• Demonstrate how AI can facilitate proposing qualitative research and analysis in a more accessible, holistic, and accurate developing survivor-led research
• Inspire attendees to thoughtfully leverage AI for social good in a survivor-centered way
This training equips professionals with the skills to establish Peer-Led Support Groups tailored for survivors of trafficking, specifically focusing on leveraging virtual spaces to enhance accessibility. Participants will learn effective strategies for creating a supportive online environment where survivors can connect, share experiences, and foster a sense of community. Attendees will gain practical insights into facilitating meaningful discussions, utilizing virtual tools, and addressing potential challenges unique to online platforms. This training aims to empower participants with the tools needed to build a virtual community that enhances support, connectivity, and healing for survivors of trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe virtual tools for support groups
• Discuss gains and challenges of virtual spaces for support groups and how to effectively facilitate using these platforms
• Discuss ongoing program evaluation and lessons learned by Restoring Ivy Collective
3:15 - 4:15
The global sports industry is expected to grow from $388.28 billion in 2020 to $440.77 billion in 2021. Projected to outpace global GDP, the sports industry is a lavishly oiled, complex machine that is entirely dependent on exceptionally talented individuals with the skills, drive, and discipline to chase their dreams. Oftentimes, young, socially and financially vulnerable athletes are targets for traffickers who hold the deceptive promise of wealth, fame, and opportunity. Traffickers, regularly going by the alias “recruiter,” exploit young athletes through force, fraud, and coercion for social and economic power. There is a dearth of publications, information, and vocabulary surrounding the human trafficking of athletes despite its growing threat to human rights. Though the presenters have identified specific domestic and global legal cases surrounding the topic, they also recognize that the void of information perpetuates this growing and time-sensitive issue and seek to address it. This presentation is a much-needed examination and discourse of this emerging social and public health problem. The presenters will seek to define trafficking within the global sports industry as a human rights violation, identify and explore the push and pull migration factors, and center this call-to-action as an international human rights issue by utilizing methodologies such as case study analysis and systems thinking maps.
Presentation Objectives:
• Define and conceptualize human trafficking within the sports industry through social work and public health epistemological approaches
• Discuss the challenges of conceptualizing this multifaceted social problem
• Identify the areas within the global sports industry where the human trafficking of athletes are the most prominent
• Identify and define the key vulnerabilities of athletes through the recruitment process
• Identify discuss potential solutions and next-steps to addressing this problem
Ritualistic abuse survivors have struggled to obtain adequate mental health and social support services for over twenty years. This problem has been exacerbated by a lack of trained providers and adequate social services to deal with the complex problems ritualistic abuse survivors present. Most clinicians do not receive proper training due to severe trauma topics and their symptomatology not being adequately covered in their master level training programs or in post continuing education training. Very few organizations are available to educate clinicians and survivors about the research in the field. Insurance companies often do not adequately cover services for long term treatment. Social services employees are not adequately trained to work with severe trauma survivors. There is a paucity of training regarding trauma informed services and ways to work with clients suffering from dissociative disorders. Application guidelines often make it very difficult for ritualistic abuse survivors to receive in the timelines given. Survivors may have difficulties getting to offices, getting on the Internet or filling out paperwork. This presentation will include the presenter’s own struggles receiving adequate services over the last thirty years. Issues to be discussed will include the symptomatology of dissociative disorders, attachment disorders, mood and anxiety disorders, economic problems, and social barriers. Solutions to decrease and eliminate these difficulties will be discussed. These will include public advocacy, public education, survivor training, and the building of a research base to help survivors and their helpers move forward to prevent these difficulties in the future.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the four key concepts regarding the lack of education for those working with ritualistic abuse survivors
• Describe reasons why ritualistic abuse survivors have difficulties obtaining services
• Describe ways ritualistic abuse survivors and their helpers can change the present system to increase services for these survivors
Recent years have seen increased attention towards labor trafficking among scholars, policymakers, and advocates. However, gaps in understanding persist due to underreporting, terminological confusion, a focus on sex trafficking, legal inconsistencies, varied employment contexts, and inadequate training among anti-trafficking stakeholders. Consequently, the legal system often lacks the tools to prosecute such cases, resulting in dispositions that do not adequately reflect the seriousness of labor traffickers’ crimes. This study employs structured online searches and descriptive statistical analysis to address the following questions: 1) What are the general demographic characteristics of labor traffickers in the United States? 2) What are the means of control used by labor traffickers in the United States? and 3) What is the disposition outcome for labor trafficking cases in the United States? The findings focus on several key areas: 1) labor trafficker demographics, 2) typologies of labor trafficking settings, 3) recruitment strategies and techniques, 4) means of control, 5) locations of arrest, and 6) crime typologies and legal outcomes per trafficker. These findings highlight diverse demographics among traffickers, variations in labor trafficking settings, recruitment strategies, means of control, arrest locations, and legal outcomes. Legal outcomes revealed a mix of labor trafficking charges, immigration-related offenses, and white-collar crimes, with only one third of cases resulting in convictions for labor trafficking. These findings highlight several critical points: the inconsistency in labor trafficking prosecution across U.S. courts, the urgent need for improved data collection on labor trafficking, and the importance of addressing foreign-national traffickers exploiting their own cultural communities.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss ongoing factors resulting in limited understanding and research on labor trafficking, including underreporting, terminological confusion, a focus on sex trafficking, legal inconsistencies, varied employment contexts, and inadequate training among anti-trafficking stakeholders
• Present key findings from the study regarding labor trafficking in the United States, including demographic characteristics of traffickers, means of control used, and disposition outcomes of labor trafficking cases
• Discuss the implications of the findings, including the challenges in prosecuting labor trafficking cases, the need for improved data collection, and the need to address foreign-national traffickers targeting their own cultural communities
The MN Boys+ project, led by the presenter, investigates the overlooked issue of sexual exploitation and abuse of boys and gender-diverse youth (boys+) in Minnesota. Using a mixed-methods approach, this study employed an online survey, semi-structured interviews, and group learning workshops to examine individuals’ experiences within interconnected social systems, exploring the perspectives of frontline service providers (FSPs). The online survey gathered quantitative data from 40 diverse participants. 25 semi-structured interviews provided in-depth insights, with data analyzed using thematic analysis. Three interactive learning workshops with stakeholders generated actionable recommendations. The research covers the journeys of affected boys+ from risk factors and experiences of exploitation to help-seeking, accessing services, barriers faced, and the availability and quality of existing services. The study reveals a spectrum of interrelated vulnerabilities, the pivotal role of early adolescence, the prominence of offenders known to the young person, widespread stigma hindering disclosure, and major gaps in trauma-informed, gender-inclusive services. The project asserts the need to move beyond reductive assumptions about masculine invulnerability and deviance to develop a nuanced understanding of boys’ experiences. This requires investment in marginalized youths’ voices, trauma-informed practices, comprehensive services, and multi-sector coordination. The MN Boys+ project represents an initial step in establishing a foundation of data and insights to inform more extensive national research and analysis focused on boys across diverse sexual orientations, gender identities, and backgrounds, advocating for a substantial, national effort to advance knowledge of childhood sexual exploitation among male-identifying youth.
Presentation Objectives:
• Highlight the often-overlooked issue of sexual exploitation and abuse faced by boys and gender-diverse youth
• Showcase the spectrum of vulnerabilities these young people face and the prevalence of known offenders
• Discuss the challenges faced by boys and gender-diverse youth when seeking help, including stigma and lack of trauma-informed services
• Advocate for the importance of research and data collection to inform intervention and prevention strategies
Street prostitution is deeply intertwined with substance use. Women who attempt to exit both prostitution and substance use often lack sufficient resources to do so, and they end up returning to substance use, prostitution, or both. Such a relapse into drugs or a return to prostitution is still often viewed as a personal failure. Low recovery capital has been used to explain relapse among certain marginalized populations. Recovery capital is a recent framework which refers to the individual’s sum of all internal and external assets that may assist in their recovery process. It includes four categories: physical, human, social, and cultural capital. However, this framework does not relate to the role of actual relapses in the recovery process, despite their common occurrence. In-depth interviews with 29 women formerly engaged in street prostitution and substance use in a large urban area were used to probe women about their relapse and recovery experiences. This study demonstrates the value of repeat recovery setbacks, what the presenter terms “cumulative attempt capital”: lessons learned from previous recovery attempts. The presenter argues that previous attempts improve women’s social and professional networks, help them learn from past mistakes, improve and maintain their health, and provide them with a sense of self-efficacy. This research expands our understanding of the positive role failed attempts play in one’s recovery. Such reframing by service providers can alleviate a sense of shame and low self-worth for women in street prostitution and substance use and has implications for policy and program development.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview of the study of the facilitators and challenges of women’s exiting journeys out of street prostitution and substance use
• Describe the framework of recovery capital for people who are recovering from prostitution and substance use
• Introduce the new tool of cumulative attempt capital, which can be used with clients at intake, and demonstrate its utility and benefits for women exiting street prostitution
We are at a conference dedicated to advocacy and social justice. Beyond people, populations, situations, and issues that demand advocacy and social justice, how do we actually do it? How do we go from seeing an issue needing addressed into positively doing something about it? How do we see people in need and effectively step up and help and/or support them? How do we start? Where do we start? What do we do? The Levels of Advocacy & Social Justice (LASJ) provide a framework to conceptualize and implement effective advocacy and social justice efforts. Expanding outward from a person or issue, the LASJ model depicts seven layers: individual, group, organizational, community, regional, state, and national. They further call upon us to take a self-inventory of our foci and abilities, coupled with our own self-care, in order to be the best advocates we can be. This presentation will aid direct service providers and concerned community members alike with foundational principles and practical tools to implement change through advocacy and social justice. The LASJ model will be provided in detail, with practical examples for each level. The accompanying self-assessment worksheet will also be provided for participants to evaluate their own strengths, goals, and self-care. All materials will be provided for free and can be immediately implemented. This in turn helps support conference attendees taking instantaneous action in areas they learn more about in other sessions of this conference.
Presentation Objectives:
• Define and categorize the LASJ layers and their use in active engagement for justice, equity, diversity, and inclusion
• Distinguish and evaluate a personalized readiness self-assessment and strategies for self-care
• Provide tangible tools and resources that can be used immediately to effective change
Zambia's political institutions have publicly made declarations to dismantle the perpetuation of abuse and traumatization of children by ratifying several national and international treaties over the past several decades. The Anti-Human Trafficking Act No.11 of 2008 represents an attempt by the Zambian government to address the challenges of forced labor in a systematic way. It was designed to make human trafficking illegal, create preventative measures, and prosecute individuals who engage in the promotion of human trafficking. However, there is a disconnection between the magnitude of laws enacted and their subsequent implementation. Are these laws more performative in nature and how can the government effectively shift towards quality implementation? What are the long-term causes of failing to provide quality policy evaluation and policy analysis? With recent legislative developments, particularly the enactment of Amendment No. 16 in 2022 to the 2008 Anti-Human Trafficking Act, there is a pressing need for comprehensive research to assess its impact and identify areas for improvement. This presentation will uncover insights into the efficacy of implemented strategies, unintended consequences, and recommendations for enhancing the future outcomes of trafficked children. Attendees will walk away with a deep understanding of human trafficking in the Zambian context and how laws that are enacted without further implementation analysis do further harm than good for key stakeholders.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss risk factors of human trafficking for youth in Zambia
• Highlight the Zambian government's attempt to address human trafficking
• Suggest mechanisms to analyze policy implementation
• Describe ways to mitigate human trafficking for child labor in Zambia
The FOCUS (Finding youth, Outreach, Comprehensive assessment and immediate services, Unified long-term services, and Service evaluation) Project is a collaborative program in Lucas County, Ohio that involves working with community agencies to identify youth at risk for human trafficking through assessment and to refer those at risk to a human trafficking intervention and other related services as needed. This presentation will provide an overview of the FOCUS Project, including validation of the FOCUS-S assessment for youth, an overview of building a continuum of care, and a review of de-identified assessment data. Attendees will learn about the process of creating a validated screening tool for youth, understand the steps and lessons learned to building a continuum of care in collaboration with community partners, and review descriptive information regarding who is at risk and what the most prevalent risk factors were for youth involved in the project.
Presentation Objectives:
• Review the process of creating a validated screening tool for youth through the utilization of research and measurement strategies
• Describe the steps and lessons learned when building a continuum of care in collaboration with community agencies who work with youth
• Discuss who is at risk for trafficking and other related services and what risk factors were most prevalent through a review of deidentified assessment data
4:30 - 5:00
Wrap-Up Session
Thursday, September 19, 2024
9:00 - 9:30
Morning Welcome
9:45 - 10:45
Dr. Kristen Szabla was born into darkness. Specifically, she was born into a black, cataclysmic web of sexual abuse and exploitation. Dr. Szabla will describe her story of overcoming, not only to bring societal awareness to these all-too-common nefarious acts against humanity, but to bring hope, healing, and ultimately social and policy change. This presentation will chronicle how Dr. Szabla used her knowledge of neurobiology to expedite her journey from the helpless victim state to an empowered survivor/thriver state. Participants will experientially learn not only how the brain functions but how trauma damages and maladaptively wires specific areas of the brain. By understanding the neurobiologic underpinnings of trauma, participants will discover how traumatized individuals are held in a victim-like state, seemingly incapable of change. In addition, the concept of the trauma triangle will be discussed. Using personal examples and visual illustrations, participants will explore strategies as to how to utilize the power of the brain to transform the trauma triangle, potentiate brain rewiring, and expedite healing. This presentation is designed to be accessible for all audiences, regardless of their familiarity with neurobiologic concepts.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide a synopsis of the survivor’s life experience
• Provide an overview of the brain in action to explain the neurobiologic impact of trauma and how trauma keeps individuals in a victimized state
• Introduce the concept of the Trauma Triangle
• Teach tactics to overcome the Trauma Triangle to potentiate the transformation from victim to survivor/thriver
This presentation will explore the relationship between climate change and forms of forced and child labor. The role of extractive economic practices, war and conflict, and ongoing genocides will also be explored. This presentation utilizes community-based participatory research methods, including findings from grassroots and survivor-led organizations, to identify best and promising practices for the prevention and mitigation of forced labor and environmental plunder. Grounded in the theories of Fanon and Rodney, the presenter will draw upon the work of survivor-led organizations to explore solutions, including models for sustainability and community-based prevention models. Organizations discussed will include Friends of the Congo, the Free Alabama Movement, and Liyang Network. Case studies from U.S. national and international news sources will be used to contextualize the impact of forced labor and climate change on migrant workers, incarcerated peoples, youth, and frontline environmental defenders. Suggestions for research, policy, and practice will be explored at the end of the presentation. There will be opportunity at the end for discussion, including sharing out of commitments towards addressing the issue of forced labor, as well as partnering strategically with individuals and organizations working to combat labor trafficking and/or climate change. Resources will be included at the end, before opening up for a 15-minute Q&A with the panelist.
Presentation Objectives:
• Investigate the relationship of climate change & forced labor
• Explore the impacts of extractive economies on people and the land
• Explore cross-sectoral solutions to human & environmental exploitation
• Commit to at least one tangible action towards co-creating an abundant world
Foreign national survivors of human trafficking experience a variety of barriers and needs related to their foreign national status. Serving this population often demands comprehensive responses that attend to immigration status, culture, language, nationality, and more. Added barriers arise surrounding awareness of labor trafficking, as it is widely lesser-known and more difficult to identify but makes up over 70% of trafficking cases among foreign nationals, according to current data. Particularly for undocumented individuals, meaning those without legal immigration status (i.e., a visa), steep barriers to stability and recovery arise from inability to obtain immigration relief, lawful employment, public benefits, and state identification. These barriers exacerbate vulnerabilities that put them at risk of trafficking. Certain immigration remedies are available to this group, including specialized pathways to status. However, immigration applications can take years for approval, meanwhile leaving these barriers to stability and recovery in place. Consequently, supporting foreign national survivors of human trafficking, especially those of whom are undocumented, requires a long-term, comprehensive, and community-based approach. This presentation will discuss these barriers, examine labor trafficking for this population, and showcase several available remedies, including pathways to immigration status. This session will also examine ways we make certain populations more vulnerable to human trafficking and practices for removing barriers to relief.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe barriers to services facing foreign national survivors of human trafficking and provide them attendees with guidance on how to reduce them
• Improve attendees’ ability to understand and identify labor trafficking, particularly as it may present in the cases involving foreign national survivors
• Discuss key remedies available to foreign national survivors of trafficking, best practices, and innovative approaches
What if you were a victim of human trafficking but had no voice to tell your story? Kim and Marci—one artist, one writer, two voices for the Silent Ones. Let them introduce you to the Strawberry Girls. The Strawberry Girls are Moroccan women recruited each year to pick "red gold" in the strawberry fields of Spain. The shocking reality is that many of these vulnerable women are then lured into sex trafficking through lies, deception, and empty promises. Once they step foot in the brothel, they are trapped, and it will take a miracle for them to get out. But miracles do happen! One day, a safe house called and asked Marci to translate for a Moroccan woman who had just been rescued. This woman was a “Strawberry Girl.” In Marci’s continued work with these women, she began to identify a human trafficking line between Morocco and Spain. Unwilling to stay silent, Marci began writing their stories. Her friend and professional artist, Kim, began painting their stories. Through Kim's soulful artwork and Marci's poetic words from their Strawberry Girls Project, they invite you to step into the shoes of the Strawberry Girls and journey with them from slavery to freedom. Kim and Marci will guide participants through the experiences of the Strawberry Girls and inspire them to use their own unique talents and passions to join the anti-human trafficking movement in their own communities and around the world. What if you could make a difference right where you are?
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the 4-stage journey of The Strawberry Girls from Morocco to Spain, identifying common patterns of human trafficking victimization around the world, such as deception, lies, empty promises, and movement of people
• Demonstrate how to use one’s passions and talents to raise awareness of trafficking
• Invite participants to consider using their unique passions and talents to join the anti-human trafficking movement in their own communities and around the world
This presentation introduces an AI-based campaign aimed at raising awareness about the harms of prostitution and combating sex trafficking. At its core, the initiative is to raise awareness of the situation of women in prostitution and recognition of the harms of prostitution, to act by providing accurate information and education, and to reduce the demand and social legitimization of prostitution. This is based on the understanding that women in the cycle of prostitution are the affected party, and that prostitution creates lasting harm to women. The strategy involves collaborating with partners including Naama, Shiran, D-ID, and potentially others, employing AI technology combined with creative storytelling to authentically convey the survivors' experiences while ensuring their anonymity. This approach fosters empathy and compassion towards these women and also supports their recovery and societal reintegration. Furthermore, by educating the public to reduce the consumption of prostitution, the campaign directly contributes to the fight against human trafficking, particularly of women. Highlighting the critical need for such an initiative, the presentation discusses the significance of lighting the damages of prostitution. It underscores the potential for societal transformation through increased awareness, reduced stigma, and supports the rehabilitation of women exiting prostitution. By promoting a social environment that condemns prostitution and recognizes women as victims of life circumstances, the campaign aims to encourage more women to seek help, and ultimately, to contribute to the prevention of prostitution and related issues such as human trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Illuminate the harms of prostitution and sex trafficking through an innovative AI-based campaign
• Foster empathy and support for the recovery and reintegration of women affected by prostitution and sex trafficking
• Educate and alter public perception, reducing the consumption of prostitution and combating sex trafficking
Work on the frontlines addressing human trafficking inevitably impacts the mind, body, and spirit. Being immersed in the impact of trauma, evil, and suffering will take a toll, but can also lead to a deeper understanding of self and others. Individuals working closely with trauma must be attuned to the impact of this work to remain in a position of effectiveness. The presenters believe that because vicarious trauma is an inevitability for anyone working with human trafficking or other forms of social injustice, having an understanding of it, being able to recognize symptoms in both individuals and organizations, and having a proactive plan for preventing and mitigating it is crucial. This presentation will define vicarious trauma, provide data from interviews conducted with service providers, and provide an opportunity for self-reflection as well as ideas for how to conceptualize and implement self-care and organizational-care.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the nature of vicarious trauma in both individuals and organizations, including contributors and symptoms
• Present data from interviews with providers on their described impact of vicarious trauma and what they have found helpful to reduce and mitigate impact
• Identify personal symptoms of secondary trauma
• Discuss the role of self-care and organizational care and present a practical way to conceptualize and practice self-care
People who have experienced a human rights violation are the ones who best know its root causes, consequences, implications, and solutions. Therefore, survivors should be at the heart of approaches to combat human trafficking. In fact, research in other human rights fields has documented successful outcomes of survivor inclusion. Free the Slaves and HAART Kenya initiated this research across East and Central Africa to better understand: 1) Which gaps and challenges limit inclusive survivor engagement in the counter trafficking sector? 2) How are organizations currently engaging survivors? and 3) How can organizations in East & Central Africa improve their inclusion of survivors? All presenters were part of the research team. From the start of the research, people with lived experience of trafficking were active as consultants, researchers, and interviewees. The research design followed a trauma-informed approach throughout. Findings and recommendations are based on interviews with 18 survivor advocates and survivor leaders from Cameroon, DRC, Kenya, Malawi, Tanzania, Ethiopia, Rwanda, Uganda, and South Sudan. Additionally, the counter-trafficking organizations they engaged with answered an online survey. The research lead to practical recommendations on how organizations can enhance survivor inclusion. The report also hopes to strengthen and encourage survivors of trafficking, survivor advocates, and leaders in their engagements with organizations. While research and recommendations are particularly informative for survivor advocates/leaders and counter trafficking organizations in Central and East Africa, it may also inspire others who wish to work for human rights more inclusively.
Presentation Objectives:
• Inspire and inform survivors of trafficking, survivor advocates, and leaders in their engagement with organizations
• Share findings and recommendations with organizations and individuals who want to improve and professionalize their survivor engagement
• Describe the inclusive and trauma-informed methodology used for this research
Survivor-Led Solutions (a nonprofit that focuses on leadership, professional development, and LeadHer Retreats for survivor leaders) is an opportunity to observe the lifespan of a survivor and find a safe space to continue leadership, professional development, and ongoing mental health services. Sharing the story from victim to survivor, from advocate to influencer, this presentation will help law enforcement agencies, mental health, and medical providers empower survivors to become the subject matter experts that they are. Understanding how to rally survivors holistically and stabilize and promote them in different areas within this work, survivor leaders are entrepreneurs in this field in a new way. The change is necessary, and the information is essential. This training will provide an advanced level of understanding of the psyche of the survivor from victim to warrior.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain the lifespan of a survivor from victim to warrior
• Describe basic principles of the psyche and how to empower survivors
• Provide critical key terms and points of transition that every survivor makes
• Offer law enforcement, mental health, and medical teams tools for best practices
11:15 - 12:15
This presentation offers a comprehensive exploration of human trafficking through the lens of an ecosystem perspective, integrating thorough research, poignant case studies, and actionable solutions. By adopting a multi-dimensional approach, it seeks to provide a holistic strategy for combatting this pervasive issue. Central to this strategy is the implementation of a hub and spoke framework, strategically leveraging accurate data to unite diverse stakeholders in a concerted effort toward eradication. Key components of the presentation include a meticulous gap analysis to identify critical areas for intervention, as well as a PESTEL analysis to contextualize the socio-political landscape surrounding human trafficking. Moreover, it outlines a survivor-centered response within the hub and spoke framework, emphasizing the importance of prioritizing the needs and experiences of survivors in our collective efforts. The presentation elucidates the essential elements of successful coordination and collaboration among stakeholders, highlighting the significance of partnering and mutual support in achieving meaningful impact. By fostering a culture of collaboration and leveraging resources effectively, we can cultivate a unified front against human trafficking. Ultimately, this presentation advocates for a comprehensive and collaborative approach to tackling human trafficking, grounded in robust research, practical solutions, and a steadfast commitment to collective impact. It serves as a call to action for stakeholders across various sectors to unite in the fight against this grave violation of human rights.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe current gaps in the landscape hindering effective survivor identification and support
• Explain the interconnected nature of areas of responsibility
• Provide key tools for helping improve collective impact initiatives to serve survivors with excellence
The presenter met “Jane Doe” when she was a 13-year-old victim of human trafficking. It took almost two years of investigation, interviewing suspects, and collecting evidence until law enforcement arrested 170 men and women including her biological mother. There were over 50,000 pages of social media evidence with thousands of chats, pictures, and videos documenting her abuse. At the center of all this evidence was one little girl who needed to be protected. One of the teams’ biggest concerns was keeping Jane Doe safe and her identity protected. The team used the pseudonym “Jane Doe” in every single filing with the Court. They redacted the evidence to make sure that her privacy was protected and that she was safe before the prosecution began. Once the discovery process began, the presenter filed almost 100 protective orders to keep her identity hidden from the public. This included editing out every piece of information that could be used to identify her. This presentation will help prosecutors, law enforcement, and other allied professionals prepare for a human trafficking case. It will provide tips and ideas on how to prepare voluminous digital evidence for court while protecting your victim. The presenter will discuss the things she learned, what she would do differently, and some of the real difficulties she experienced moving forward. She will also talk about her trauma and how it influenced the case as it went through the criminal justice system.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the types of privileged information that exists and why it should be protected
• Discuss the type of preparation that goes into an investigation/prosecution of a case this size
• Discuss and explain what worked, what didn’t, and what was learned in hindsight
Christian faith-based NGOs (CFBOs) are major players in caring for survivors, but public representation of female survivors can reinforce stigma and feelings of powerlessness among the women they aim to help. Interviews with CFBO representatives revealed perspectives attributing trafficking to cultural factors, parenting, and the Khmer Rouge legacy’s impact on families. However, these portrayals tend to be generalized rather than reflecting survivors’ individual experiences and neglect to address larger systemic inequities. Interviews with trafficking survivors were a sub-group of the Butterfly Longitudinal project. They found CFBO marketing, especially when identifying survivors, led to experiences of dishonor, lost agency over their stories, and increased societal stigma. Recommendations include CFBOs partnering with survivors on ethical representation, targeting messaging to local audiences to mobilize community-level change, and refraining from using rescue and slavery narratives. Faith-based NGOs have an opportunity and a responsibility to restore dignity and power to survivors in how their stories are shared.
Presentation Objectives:
• Examine current practices in how CFBOs represent trafficking survivors in Cambodia
• Discuss the impact of CFBO marketing on survivor experiences of stigma and agency
• Provide recommendations for how faith-based NGOs can ethically portray survivors
In the decades since global and national measurement has proven elusive, communities have grappled with the challenge of measuring prevalence with imperfect data. Estimates of the scope of the problem continue to vary, with evolving systems perpetually adapting to turnover, funding fluctuations, and societal stereotypes. Understanding statewide and regional contexts beyond prosecution and other system counts have been possible through the Colorado Projects’ 10-year longitudinal community-based participatory research (CBPR). Using theoretical public health frameworks, this session focuses upon the key findings from the Colorado Projects to provide contextualized knowledge about the nature of human trafficking and who is counted, who has access to systems, who is overrepresented, and who is missing. Inclusive CBPR methods empower survivors, underserved community members, practitioners, and activists with data that help to answer the research question of how trust, equity, and effectiveness are reflected in anti-trafficking responses. Focusing upon Colorado Project 2023 findings, this session will illustrate ways communities of color including immigrant and tribal communities, individuals who hold LGBTQ+ identities, and youth experiencing homelessness continue to be more vulnerable to exploitation and human trafficking in Colorado. The session will focus on the nature of trust, equity, and effectiveness within the anti-trafficking partnerships across Colorado that contribute to these inequities, notably the lack of critical representation in partnerships necessary to be more effective. This session will engage participants in the Colorado Project research recommendations focused on inclusion, training, partnership actions, and housing needed to sustain survivor-centered trauma-informed anti- trafficking responses across urban, rural, and frontier communities.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide a brief overview of the community-based participatory research key questions and methodologies of the longitudinal Colorado Project to Comprehensively Combat Human Trafficking
• Present research findings for participants to gain insights on the nature of trust, equity, and effectiveness within the anti-trafficking partnerships across Colorado,
• Describe the implications of the recommendations within the Colorado Project 2023 Action Plan focused on inclusion, training, partnership actions, and housing needed to sustain survivor-centered trauma-informed anti-trafficking responses
The Region of Peel’s Anti-Human Sex Trafficking (AHST) Program is a unique, first of its kind program in Canada. With its three-pillar approach, the Peel AHST Program seeks to combat human trafficking through: 1) Prevention – aims to increase awareness and education of sex trafficking through advocacy and training initiatives, community engagement, and education/awareness events; 2) Intervention – aims to increase access to dedicated wrap-around services and supports for victims, survivors, and individuals at-risk through the integrated services hub; and 3) Exits/Housing – aims to increase access to dedicated, safe, and supportive housing for victims and survivors. The Peel AHST Survivor Remuneration Framework acknowledges that the voices of survivors and expertise of survivor leaders must be at the forefront of the anti-trafficking movement. In doing so, the framework advances an equitable and ethical approach to meaningfully engage with survivors by integrating a best practice model for remunerating those with lived experience based on the principles of being non-tokenistic, trauma informed, and preventing further harm. The framework provides guidelines based on identified best practices for compensating survivors of sex trafficking and maintains that organizations cannot expect survivors to offer their time and expertise pro bono. Ethical financial compensation is the only way anti-trafficking organizations can value and acquire vital survivor expertise. Increasing the ethical inclusion of survivor expertise in all aspects of programming, service delivery, policy development, and client pathways is critical to improving anti-trafficking efforts. At the same time, organizations must be cognizant of the ethical, equitable, and meaningful inclusion of survivors into organizational processes.
Presentation Objectives:
• Promote recognition that an ethical and equitable approach which incorporates the expertise of survivor leaders must be at the forefront of the anti-trafficking movement
• Discuss how to integrate a best practice model for remunerating those with lived experience based on the principles of being non-tokenistic, trauma informed, and preventing further harm
• Explains the value and importance of meaningfully engaging with survivor leaders/ individuals with lived experience
Today’s online world has led to an epidemic of victimization of children. Offenders can locate, groom, and victimize children through numerous apps. Now, with artificial intelligence (AI), offenders can create AI versions of children, manipulate photos of children, and create child sexual abuse material. They can use AI at scale to machine learn victim behavior and utilize that technology to groom at scale. This presentation will highlight current trends and dangers that artificial intelligence poses to victims and the threat to society we now face. It will cover how machine learning can mimic children’s social media accounts to use their own information against them. The presenter will go over the open web and how a simple photo at a school event can be used to exploit children. Attendees will better understand the how AI is employed by how offenders exploit children for online child exploitation and trafficking. They will also learn some safe tips to protect their own social media platforms.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss what AI and machine learning is
• Explain how offenders are using different technology to make it easier to groom victims
• Explain how AI will be used by offenders in trafficking and child exploitation
Maya Tamang, 44, was born into a low-income family in a rural area of Nepal and is the mother of one daughter. She was trafficked to India when she was eight years old. 500 minor Nepalese girls were rescued during the 1996 Indian government raid on all brothels in the nation. When she returned to Kathmandu, WOREC granted her two years of shelter, and then they assisted her in reintegrating with her family in her village. She was forced to move to a different place because of the stigma and discrimination against her HIV condition. Later, she married a man from a different caste. She suffered violence from her husband, and sadly, their marriage was not able to withstand it. Maya started Shakti Samuha, the first organization in the world, founded by human trafficking survivors together with fifteen other survivors. She is employed with the organization. She faces a number of intersectional challenges in her reintegration. In 2013, she was given the opportunity to take part in a participatory action research study conducted by University of Calgary PhD candidate, Rita Dhungel. The study provided her with a safe and judgment-free platform to reflect on her own intersectional oppression and raise her voice, which had been silenced, through the use of photovoice and media conferences. Maya Tamang, who is currently working as a reintegration officer with Shakti Samuha, will share her journey from oppression to liberation. She will also discuss how engaging in participatory action research gave her more self-assurance and empowered her to support campaigns that aim to prevent, protect, and prosecute human trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Help participants critically understand the challenges of trafficking survivors in reintegration
• Share the power of trafficking survivors in their reintegration
• Highlight how participatory action research provided Maya with the opportunity to raise her silenced voice and become involved in advocacy practice
The Northern Ohio REACH Coalition rightly prides itself on helping victims grow to become survivors and then thrivers. We applaud these gains. Those of us with sexual convictions are never victims. However, we can be viewed as survivors of our prison journey even if that journey was due to our choices. This promotes community safety. Sexual offenders have the ability to learn how to thrive and make a difference in their communities. Everyone can feel safer and more productive when both survivors and those who have abused also thrive. This involves accepting the consequences of past behavior and advocating for humanity and recovery. The judgement of many people creates barriers. Many people believe that pedophilia is incurable and untreatable, but research and hard work allow many of us to thrive. Robert Longo lists seventeen areas where those of us with sexual convictions need to achieve for community safety, which will be examined in further detail in this presentation with the end goal of helping people thrive. In this session, the presenters will discuss the importance of involving mental health agencies to assist in confronting any denial or minimization. This also is important when family reunification takes place. A cooperative arrangement of individuals, family members, mental health, and law enforcement can work together to enhance community safety and a thriving population. The more we establish this sense of community, the better the opportunity to have restorative individuals all living together. The presentation will feature both discussion and slides to reinforce the concepts of healing.
Presentation Objectives:
• Demonstrate the challenge of reentry and regaining trust
• Describe how to challenge and refrain our assumptions about life
• Demonstrate the importance of taking full responsibility for our past behaviors
Law enforcement, service providers, and medical responders experience sustained exposure to child maltreatment, sexual assaults, and human trafficking. The resulting effects can be devastating and include substance abuse, increased rates of suicide, marital distress, depression and anxiety, and decreased physical wellness. This presentation will focus on learning more about vicarious trauma and gaining tools to assess our personal experience with vicarious trauma to improve our wellbeing. The presenter will differentiate between vicarious trauma and secondary traumatic stress, compassion fatigue, burn out, moral suffering, and post-traumatic stress disorder to understand the impact high-stress work environments have on the wellbeing of those in the profession. Discussion regarding personal experiences, cultural changes within the workplace, and the normalization of vicarious trauma and compassion fatigue will be a main priority during this session. The presenter will include various resilience strategies to assist attendees in self-care routines, which also ensures less turnover and better services provided to the victims they serve.
Presentation Objectives:
• Assist attendees to recognize their own levels of compassion fatigue and vicarious trauma by learning about them and the related effects of high-stress work
• Discuss the need to normalize vicarious trauma in high stress work and access tools and resources to improve their personal and professional lives
• Describe how to advocate for culture change in the workplace by discussing the importance of leadership buy-in and tools to make a difference
Lunch Networking Sessions
12:30 - 1:30
1:45 - 2:45
Approximately 90 million migrants are living and working outside their home countries, many seeking security and sustainable livelihoods. These migrants often take on "3D jobs" characterized by low wages, little security, and hazardous conditions. Forced labor affects millions globally, with 49.6 million individuals trapped in modern slavery in 2021, including 27.6 million enduring forced labor. Of these, 17.3 million suffer exploitation in the private sector, and 3.9 million are victims of state-sanctioned forced labor. Shockingly, 6 million women and girls, along with 12% of children, are subjected to forced labor. Addressing decent work deficiencies in the informal economy is vital in combating this issue. This study aims to evaluate safeguarding strategies for individuals affected by forced labor exploitation-related human trafficking and child trafficking along the Mediterranean migration route, aligning with sustainable development goals. Semi-structured and qualitative in-depth interviews were conducted with experts from Italy and Turkey. A total of 46 participants, including 15 from Italy and 31 from Turkey, were involved. Grounded theory guided data analysis using MAXQDA 2020 Pro Analytics software, revealing 2,942 codes, 17 sub-themes, and 4 main themes. These themes covered victim profiles, available services, challenges in service provision, and proposals for an effective protection system. The conclusion and discussion section compared results within the Council of Europe Convention framework, allowing for a comparative analysis between Italy and Turkey. Recommendations were made to address identified gaps in combating forced labor exploitation.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss protective measures for those impacted by forced labor exploitation, specifically human and child trafficking along the Mediterranean migration route
• Describe how to seek alignment with sustainable development goals to ensure effective safeguarding strategies
This presentation will examine familial exploitation from a family-system perspective. Take a deep dive into the behavioral indicators, family dynamics, and offender characteristics that contribute to family-controlled exploitation. Exploitation of this kind involves family members selling their minor children for money, drugs, or something else of value (e.g., access, prestige, or recreation) and typically includes manufacturing of child sex abuse material. Families who exploit their children commercially often have adversities, dysfunctions, and disorders that create a household dynamic of coercion and secrecy, making identification and intervention extremely difficult. These children often attend school, church, and other community functions, but go unnoticed as needing assistance. Exploitation of this kind causes severe psychological trauma, negatively impacting the individual throughout their lifespan. While identification is difficult, it is not impossible. Join this session for a closer look at familial exploitation, examine key identifiers, and discuss intervention strategies throughout the lifespan.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide a thorough understanding of familial trafficking, including dysfunctional household dynamics
• Identify key behavioral indicators of the family system and victim/survivor
• Explore survivor-informed intervention strategies across the lifespan
It is well known that individuals with complex trauma and especially those with marginalized identities have not received quality mental health care. Many of these reasons stem from budgeting and other systemic challenges of providing therapy in community mental health. However, with individuals connected to commercial sex, clinicians are also missing key cultural and trauma informed pieces. Therapists often even over focus on trauma in commercial sex, often fetishizing the individual, or they feel they cannot go near those experiences and discuss them and avoid them at all costs. This presentation will explore providing therapy as an ally and how to provide quality care. It will explore the benefits of trauma informed therapy, use of EMDR, and particularly Dolores Mosquera’s progressive approach theory to provide healing for individuals connected to commercial sex. She will discuss the challenges of using standard protocol of EMDR with individuals who have been connected to the commercial sex trade. She will explore common themes that occurred when attempting to provide EMDR. She will discuss her protocols that allowed individuals to benefit from therapy and experience relief. She will explore how to provide EMDR to individuals currently in the life without flooding or re-traumatization. She will provide case examples and discuss the benefits seen. Finally, she will explore the importance of culturally attuned care as well as having access to quality and thorough trauma treatment to survivors. She will expand on how providing quality care is a social justice and rights issue for individuals connected to commercial sex.
Presentation Objectives:
• Increase knowledge regarding therapy provided to commercial sex trade survivors
• Explore how EMDR can support healing for commercial sex trade survivors
• Support attendees to identify how they can increase their clinical support of individuals in commercial sex through their organizations
• Identify how providing quality care to individuals connected to commercial sex is a social justice issue
Effective partnerships between law enforcement and the communities they serve are a key component in effectively identifying and assisting victims of human trafficking and investigating and prosecuting traffickers. Agencies that focus on the three principles of community policing – partnerships, problem solving, and organizational change - have seen success in building trust and strengthening relationships between law enforcement and the communities they serve; including populations that may be particularly vulnerable to trafficking. This session will focus on promising practices in community policing approaches to human trafficking with the goal to explore how the law enforcement response to human trafficking might be strengthened throughout the field. Panelists will also discuss available resources and technical assistance available to the field.
Presentation Objectives:
• Identify promising practices for combatting human trafficking
• Provide collaborative strategies for engaging with services providers and survivors
• Identify investigative strategies using community policing approaches
Coercive control is a cornerstone of sex trafficking. It entraps survivors in the vicious cycle of abuse and keeps them under the trafficker’s power - even though the door is “wide open” for them to leave. Understanding coercive control and its deep impacts on survivors is key to understanding the nuances of sex trafficking and supporting survivors in a transformative way. Using an intersectional feminist approach that is trauma-informed and survivor-centric, Marissa will explore coercive control in the context of sex trafficking. This knowledge is a feature of Aura Freedom's award-winning human trafficking prevention work and their ground-breaking online Human Trafficking Info Hub. Through various examples, Marissa will examine the many forms that coercive control takes, as well as the different control tactics used by traffickers and how they affect survivors when accessing services. Pulling from her own experience supporting survivors, as well as from Aura Freedom’s survivor-informed curricula, Marissa will share how to provide trauma-informed survivor support that acknowledges, considers, and understands coercive control. She will examine the criminalization of survivors as a form of coercive control, and stress the importance of employing the UN Non-Punishment Principle in the anti-trafficking movement. Attendees will gain frontline strategies and grassroots community knowledge to inform their work, support survivors in a good way, and ultimately prevent human trafficking. Most importantly, attendees will learn how to flip the script from “Why don’t they just leave?” to truly understanding coercive control.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide insight into the complexities and nuances of sex trafficking by exploring coercive control and its intense effects on survivors
• Present frontline survivor support strategies for successful human trafficking prevention rooted in human rights, intersectional feminism, equity, and empowerment
• Highlight transformative, trauma-informed service provision to prevent re-exploitation and disrupt cycles of intergenerational trafficking
• Examine the criminalization of sex trafficking survivors as a form of Coercive Control, and the importance of the UN Non-Punishment Principle in the anti-trafficking movement
Deaf individuals are at a higher risk of maltreatment and trafficking than the general population due to systemic vulnerabilities. Specifically, without culturally responsive and linguistically accessible services, Deaf clients (both adults and children) may struggle with reporting maltreatment and receiving services for trauma after experiencing maltreatment. There is an increased risk of commercial sexual exploitation of children and adults who have been maltreated, and as estimates show that deaf children have a high risk of abuse, it is likely that deaf children and adults experience CSEC at a high rate due to systemic issues. This training will discuss the needs of Deaf populations related to trafficking service provision and collaboration with interpreters, Deaf serving agencies, and other supports. Attendees will learn about Deaf community considerations in terms of risk and protective factors in anti-trafficking; cultural and linguistic accessibility; and specialized needs for safe houses, case management, and other types of service provision, including how to work with Deaf led organizations, interpreters, and consultants.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain how to reduce risk and safety issues with Deaf youth and adult clients as providers in anti-trafficking
• Discuss how to engage with Deaf survivors from an empowerment framework and resources for support
• Discuss how to find resources for accommodations and cultural competency building
Human trafficking has a complex relationship with artificial intelligence (AI). AI serves as both a powerful ally and potential adversary in the battle against modern-day slavery, with our prioritization of humanity determining the victor. While acting as Project Manager for a human trafficking abolition organization, Property Manager for the Anchorage, Alaska Emergency Women’s Shelter, and Criminal Justice Technician in the Sex Offender Registry for the Alaska Department of Safety, Sabrina faced sex traffickers preying on the vulnerable and learned how they run their businesses. The presenter will critically examine the darker side of AI and ethical considerations in the development and implementation of AI tools, with a call to prioritize human rights and privacy. While AI holds immense promise for bolstering anti-trafficking efforts, it simultaneously poses risks and ethical concerns that demand vigilant consideration. Highlighting the positive aspects, the presentation explores how AI technologies can enhance the identification, prevention, and intervention strategies employed by human trafficking advocates. From predictive analytics to data-driven awareness campaigns, the potential for AI to revolutionize the field is underscored. In conclusion, the presentation offers recommendations for a balanced approach, urging the integration of ethical guidelines into AI initiatives. It calls upon the audience to actively participate in shaping AI policies that prioritize the welfare of vulnerable populations. The talk serves as a thought-provoking exploration of the challenges and opportunities at the intersection of AI and the fight against human trafficking, urging a collective commitment to responsible and human-centric AI practices.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide a comprehensive exploration of the dual role played by artificial intelligence in the context of human trafficking
• Highlight specific instances and applications where AI has positively impacted anti-trafficking efforts, showcasing how AI tools can be leveraged for identification, prevention, and intervention strategies
• Actively engage the audience in a discussion about the ethical implications of using AI in anti-trafficking initiatives
• Offer recommendations for a balanced and ethical approach to utilizing AI in the fight against human trafficking
The dearth of available information on early onset commercial sexual exploitation (CSE) is a serious knowledge gap. This study sought to identify common patterns and variations in the life histories of adults who experienced CSE prior to the age 11. A community-based participatory research approach was used to conduct interviews at two and three timepoints with 10 adults whose CSE began below age 11. Most participants (n = 8) identified as cis women (Mage = 38). The average age of CSE onset was 4.78 years. Primary traffickers were biological family, step/adoptive caregivers, daycare provider, and a neighbor. Reflective thematic analysis was used to identify six themes: (1) Stolen identities and isolated childhoods; (2) Hidden lives amid severe, chronic abuse; (3) Indifferent to bad to worse family dynamics; (4) Structural oppression: Churches, cults, and patriarchy; (5) Surviving complex trauma; and (6) In the pursuit of justice. Surviving chaotic and unpredictable childhoods that included caregivers’ severe mental illness and chronic abuse resulted in a range of cognitive, somatic, and behavioral responses, such as dissociation and self-injurious behaviors. Although participants were not offered services after exiting CSE and traffickers were never prosecuted, they displayed a strong commitment to help prevent and stop future child exploitation. This is the first study to center the experiences of adults initiated into CSE at very young ages and to use a community-engaged approach to do so. Implications for research, policy, and practice will be discussed.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe pathways into CSE that were initiated at very young ages by trusted adults
• Explore differences in CSE pathways and life course development as compared to those initiated into exploitation during adolescence
• Evaluate gaps in current prevention and intervention strategies in the anti-trafficking field
• Consider policies and programs that could better support those who experience early onset CSE
3:15 - 4:15
Familial trafficking has only recently been brought into the mainstream conversations around human trafficking, but there is still a lot we don’t understand. The barriers a child faces that has been trafficked by a family member starts with identification and continues throughout the “system.” What happens when they hit a barrier and either fall through the cracks or are placed in a more harmful situation? These are some of our most vulnerable youth. Join the presenters to find out more about these barriers, the sporadic safety nets that are in place, and their suggestions for systemic change to better address these issues.
Presentation Objectives:
• Define familial trafficking and the difficulties in identification
• Discuss the barriers throughout the system that a child trafficked by a family member might encounter
• Challenge the traditional system as it relates to the child and consider alternatives to better serve them
At Bon Secours Mercy Health, (BSMH) their mission is to extend the compassionate ministry of Jesus by improving the health and well-being of the community and bringing good help to those in need, especially people who are poor, dying, and underserved. This is never more evident than in their trauma informed care of those being trafficked. A case presentation will be offered, along with a discussion of a healthcare system’s approach to this care including the role of forensic nurses and the trauma recovery center. Presenters will share insight into the development of training and education of health system associates located across four states, along with providing educational offerings to increase awareness of trafficking within the communities the health system serves, while developing partnerships within those areas. Additionally, presenters will discuss successes and lessons learned by a health system while developing a trauma informed care approach for those patients experiencing trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Define a trauma informed care approach for those being trafficked using the “4 R’s” of realizing, recognizing, responding, and resisting re-traumatization
• Discuss a healthcare system’s approach to the holistic needs and care of those being trafficked, including the role of forensic nurses and the trauma recovery center
• Describe two methods for building community partnerships and how their respective role contributes to the overall success of this approach
In the ever-evolving landscape of human trafficking research, the allure of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) often dominates the discourse, promising precision and rigor. Despite the numerous ethical, legal, and methodological concerns raised by researchers and communities, and known viable alternatives, RCTs continue to be the preferred, if not the required, method for many large-scale funders to combat human trafficking around the globe. Using real-world examples, the presenters will acknowledge the history and utility of RCTs while also addressing concerns regarding their misapplication, and examples of the harm the overreliance on RCTs has caused to the anti-human trafficking effort. Specifically, they will explore how the overreliance on RCTs 1) reflects a Western-centric view of development, inconsistent with the decolonial goal of empowering communities, 2) can create coercion and power imbalance between academics/researchers who know RCTs and the service providers who need funds, 3) sets back the anti-trafficking field by focusing on researcher-originated priorities, 4) perpetuates known methodological concerns, and 5) has created an overabundance of micro-level interventions conducive to an RCT design that have little practical application or applicability to the systemic concerns that perpetuate trafficking. Finally, they will present some of the many rigorous alternative methods to the RCT that center community knowledge and agency and emphasize the need for careful consideration of ethical implications, impact, and cultural sensitivities.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the history, utility of, and reliance on RCTs in the human trafficking field
• Understand the limitations and concerns regarding RCT application
• Discuss rigorous alternatives to RCT in combatting human trafficking
Federal funds for human trafficking victim programs and services in the United States have increased from approximately $10 million in 2002 to more than $90 million in 2022. This increase in fund availability, however, has not necessarily translated into meaningful or accessible services for survivors. This research examines the distribution of Department of Justice anti-trafficking funds through the Office for Victims of Crime (OVC), particularly looking at OVC recipients in Alaska. This case study of Alaska - which received more than $10 million since 2019 - highlights certain trends in OVC funding, including changes in distribution over time, emphasis on task force engagement between service providers and law enforcement, and discussions of equity and inclusion, while the reality faced by survivors can be quite different. What institutional accountability explains how the $10.7 million in federal funds have been spent in Alaska over the last decade? What do a plethora of victim service funds mean if survivors cannot access them? The presenters explore institutional mechanisms of exclusion and harm, particularly around concepts of ideal victims, complexities in collaborating with law enforcement, criminalization of trafficking survivors, and criteria to qualify for services. The implications of this research for policymakers and service providers are further explored, and suggestions are made for federal funding distribution and accountability and institutional engagement with federal funds and survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide a descriptive overview of OVC funding distribution over different types of projects and different areas of the U.S. over time
• Dive into Alaska’s case study, understanding the role of federal funding in institutional behavior and policies and exploring survivor’s experiences with these federally funded groups
• Describe the recommendations for federal funding and institutional policies based on this research
Existing literature on sex trafficking in the United States has extensively discussed the varied profiles of traffickers. However, there is a lack of research on minors trafficking other minors. In this study, data was collected from a Las Vegas police department and 27 cases were found between January 11 to December 2021 where the sex trafficker was under the age of 18. This data was collected to address the following research questions: 1) What are the socio-demographic profiles of minors involved in sex trafficking as offenders, including their age, race/ethnicity, and gender? 2) Whom do minor offenders of sex trafficking typically target or traffic, and what are the characteristics of these victims? and 3) What are the primary methods used by minor offenders to recruit victims into sex trafficking? Results show limited variation in gender and race, and include how victims were identified by law enforcement, behaviors of the traffickers including how they were recruiting and trafficking their victims, the means of control employed by the minor offenders, and case outcomes including arrest information and dispositions. These findings urge action, especially involving schools and youth safety training. School staff can aid in prevention and intervention by recognizing trafficking signs, identifying at-risk students, and reporting suspicions properly. Collaboration between law enforcement, schools, social services, and communities is crucial. It ensures comprehensive support for victims and offenders, offering counseling, rehabilitation, and legal aid. Prevention efforts should educate on healthy relationships, online safety, critical thinking, and digital literacy to empower youth against exploitation.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the background and gaps in existing literature regarding minors trafficking other minors in the context of sex trafficking in the U.S.
• Present the key findings from the study, including limited variations in gender and race among minor offenders, methods of victim identification by law enforcement, trafficker behaviors, means of control used, case outcomes, and implications for action, particularly involving schools and youth safety training
In 2017, founded by Kenyette Tisha Barnes and Oronike Odeleye, #MuteRKelly used a hybrid organizing strategy to hold accountable R&B singer Robert Sylvester Kelly, “R. Kelly”, for over 30 years of unchecked sexual violence, sex trafficking, and violence against adolescent and young adult Black women and girls. As a result of the campaign, there was a marked economic loss of approximately $4 Million in lost ticket sales, bans from urban radio, canceled concerts, media and entertainment scrutiny (most notably the docuseries, “Surviving R. Kelly”), and a Federal conviction. #MuteRKelly, created a paradigm shift and exposed how the intersections of power, misogynoir, and adultification, created a breeding ground for corruption, sex trafficking, and abuse. #MuteRKelly approached activism from an intersectional lens, understanding that the dominant players within the anti-trafficking movement often neglect the unique experiences of Black female victims of sexual violence. Next, the campaign sought to organize a diverse coalition of legislative, judicial, mental health, media, entertainment, and community partners. Finally, #MuteRKelly employed traditional grassroots organizing, including protests, rallies, and the formulation of 13 global chapters, including Berlin and Amsterdam. In this session, the presenter will provide a call to action for intersectionality in programming, reporting, and agency leadership and to divest from the systemic marginalization of BIPOC thought leaders and survivors' voices in the anti-trafficking discourse.
Presentation Objectives:
• Introduce attendees to the genesis, coalition partners, and historic progression of the #MuteRKelly Campaign
• Reinforce the concepts of intersectionality, misogynoir, and adultification and synthesize how these concepts underpinned R. Kelly's 30-year sexual abuse and sex trafficking behaviors
• Discuss how the intersections of power, race, misogynoir, and adultification underpinned the vilification of #MuteRKelly organizers and secondary trauma of R Kelly's survivors and their family members
• Discuss the weaponization of social media and lack of response by social media moderators to address the abuse, doxxing, and harassment of #MuteRKelly organizers and survivors
Join Dr. Shobana Powell and Cristian Eduardo in an exploration of the dynamics of psychological coercion in sex trafficking. They will present on how research on Biderman's Framework and cultic theory demonstrate the shared psychological coercion tactics used in sex trafficking, torture, and cults. The presenters will also discuss the practical applications for working with survivors. This workshop is beneficial to all who work in the anti-trafficking field, as psychological coercion can be one of the most common forms of control and yet one of the most difficult to identify, name, and heal from. The presenters will go beyond the basics of human trafficking, delving into the subtle manipulation tactics utilized by exploiters and providing culturally relevant case examples. The goal of this workshop is to 1) validate and normalize survivors’ experiences of psychological coercion, 2) empower mental health, law enforcement, legal, and other service providers with shared language around psychological coercion, and 3) replace movement-wide minimizing of the harms of psychological coercion with believing and supporting survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Identify shared coercion tactics in sex trafficking and torture
• Identify shared coercion tactics in sex trafficking and cults
• Learn tips for working with survivors who have experienced coercive control
Working in the field of trauma can be emotionally and mentally taxing for direct service providers. In order to be empathetic and ethical practitioners, it is crucial for professionals to prioritize their own self-care in order to effectively support survivors. With over two decades of experience in anti-trafficking and social justice work between the two of them, Brianne and Nora have seen how critical self-care is for providers in the field. Direct service providers often experience high levels of stress, compassion fatigue, and burnout due to the emotional and physical demands of their work. Throughout this presentation, the importance of self-compassion and self-awareness are emphasized as essential components of self-care. Various forms of self-care practices will be explored during this presentation; including mindfulness, breathing exercises, and self-reflection tools to better understand one’s own thought process and triggers. Trauma informed yoga combines movement, breath, and mindfulness to help providers release tension and build resilience. Overall, this presentation provides practical tools and strategies for direct service providers to cultivate self-care habits, enhance their reflective practices, and address inner conflict in a trauma-informed manner. By prioritizing their own well-being, service providers can continue to effectively support those they work with from a place of compassion and abundance. In conclusion, it is essential for direct service providers to prioritize self-care in order to prevent burnout and compassion fatigue. By incorporating regular self-care practices into their routines, providers better support others and continue doing the work they are passionate about.
Presentation Objectives:
• Increase awareness and understanding of self-care practices among direct service providers, including educating direct service providers on the importance of self-care practices in preventing burnout and compassion fatigue
• Explore the benefits and strategies of incorporating trauma-informed yoga as a self-care tool for both direct service providers and survivors, with a focus on promoting healing and empowerment through mind-body connection
• Empower direct service providers with practical strategies and resources for self-care that they can integrate into their daily routines in order to maintain their well-being, decrease stress, and continue serving survivors with compassion and effectiveness
4:30 - 5:00
Wrap-Up Session
Friday, September 20, 2024
9:00 - 9:30
Morning Welcome
9:45 - 10:45
In this presentation, Mercy will reflect on key factors for an impactful outcome of the economic empowerment trainings from the HAART (Awareness Against Human Trafficking) program. She will discuss the role of mental health, lack of resources, freedom of choice, availability of options, and long-term support mechanisms. Drawing from her individual choices and professional paths, the presentation gives an overview of a broad and diverse range of economic empowerment options. She will also share insights on the impact of economic empowerment programs on her psychological wellbeing and social status, including a gender perspective. A focus will be on long-term efficiency of economic empowerment. As a survivor advocate, Mercy will recommend actions for organizations who wish to design or redesign their own economic empowerment programs. She also hopes to inspire more organizations to set up appropriate economic empowerment programs.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview over economic empowerment program opportunities and outline their potentially profound impact
• Discuss key factors, challenges, and conditions for success and impact
• Provide recommendations for program design
• Inspire and encourage fellow survivors
Approximately 3.5% of children and adolescents in the US experience commercial sexual exploitation (CSE). There is no unified approach to assessing the needs of these youth and providing care. Few programs that have published results used objective measures of psychological functioning and those that did often failed to account for the validity, reliability, and cultural appropriateness of measures used. Anchored in research around ACEs, maltreatment, and emotion regulation (ER), the current study examined correlations between these concepts and other markers of distress (e.g., system involvement, self-harm, substance abuse, and self-reported symptoms). Relatedly, these results would then inform development of an appropriate battery of assessments, guide treatment, and enhance program development. 72 youth referred for treatment secondary to CSE provided demographic information and completed the Adverse Childhood Experiences-Questionnaire (ACE-Q) Teen Self- Report, the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), the Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI), and the Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale (DERS). As expected, high total DERS scores and high scores on the Strategies subscale were correlated with greater ACE exposure and more distress. Results support the utility of these measures in assessing the clinical presentations of and progress in treatment for youth who have experienced CSE and suggest emotion regulation may be a more desirable treatment target than symptom reduction. Implementation of such a battery would improve delivery of services both on the individual and the larger programmatic level.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the need for utilization of psychometrically reliable, valid, and culturally appropriate measures to assess youth experiencing CSE at intake and across treatment
• Explore literature related to emotion regulation and relation to ACEs and applicability to CSE and associated distress
• Provide rationale for using the DERS [along with other measures] with this population
• Discuss correlations among ACE exposure, DERS scores, psychological symptomatology, and other markers of distress
• Explore the implications for individual treatment and programming the larger level
The prevalence of killing of women and girls for ritual is higher than other geopolitical regions in Nigeria. Consequently, Nembe City Development Foundation (NCDF) in Bayelsa State received a total of $90,000 as a counterpart funding from a partnership between PACT Nigeria, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), and foundation for Partnership Initiative in the Niger Delta (PIND) under the Advocacy, Awareness, and Civic Empowerment (ADVANCE) program. The funding received was used for a capacity building program – “Add Their Voice to the Budget” (ATVB) – for all GMoU Clusters in Bayelsa State. The program designed to equip the Global Memorandum of Understanding (GMoU) Clusters with relevance skills required for peaceful engagement and compliment governments effort in the planning and implementation of the development agenda for the respective communities. A total of 61 representatives from the GMoU Clusters including youth, women leaders, and traditional rulers successfully completed the ATVB training on budget tracking and advocacy skills. Thus, the researchers examined the impact of the multinational oil companies’ CSR using GMoU model on deterring the prevalence of killing of women and girls for ritual in the region. A total of 2,400 women were sampled across the Niger Delta region in Nigeria. The results from the use of logistic regression model indicates that the meagre GMoU interventions specifically targeted at women recorded significant success in improving women’s participation in political, social, and economic activities of the region. The findings suggest that business has an obligation to help in solving problems of public concern.
Presentation Objectives:
• Critically examine the corporate social responsibility initiatives of multinational oil companies in Nigeria, with the intention of demonstrating the impact of GMoU on deterring the prevalence of killing of women and girls for ritual in the Niger Delta
• Motivate attendees to engage in policy dialogues to address the underlying drivers, and develop appropriate punitive and preventive measures to mitigate the situation; and to work with media outlets to sensitize the public about ritual killings, encourage good parenting, and promote values that discourage money-making ritual crimes
Anneke Lucas is a survivor of ritual abuse (RA), mind control, and child sex slavery to the global elite. She is an author and public speaker, leading workshops around the world, and counsels privately with other survivors. At age six, Anneke was sold by her mother into an international pedophile ring involving world leaders. Like many victims, she was used in a system of power where children were used for blackmail, as well as indoctrinated in the dark practices of this exclusive group. She received mind control training to be a sex slave to the global elite as a performer. At age 11, she was dramatically rescued from the ring by an insider. Through her experiences at the seat of worldly power, through her long, ongoing healing process, and through service, Anneke developed intricate awareness of power, both on the global and personal level. In this presentation, Anneke will address her 30-plus-year healing journey, the countless times that helplessness and powerlessness were re-experienced in the healing process and the significance of that phase of recovery. Anneke will share how people hearing her story often experience similar, difficult feelings of helplessness and powerlessness, and she will offer a way to use that discomfort as a key for personal growth and empowerment.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the experiences of a mind-controlled child sex slave
• Discuss specifics of healing from extreme power abuse
• Explain the discomfort of being confronted with the subject of RA and then used as a way into one’s own healing
Chalsea Padilla will be introducing the Nurse Advocate Program (NAP), offering an innovative approach to addressing barriers faced by individuals affected by trafficking when seeking healthcare services. Drawing on current nursing research in the Northwest Ohio area, the presentation will highlight the continued need for effective educational/training programs, resources, and support for healthcare providers (HCPs) to successfully address this vulnerable population’s needs. The focus will be on reviewing existing literature and identifying gaps in knowledge that contribute to service barriers and health disparities to provide practical solutions for HCPs and service providers in the healthcare setting. The presentation will address the unique challenges presented by individuals affected by trafficking or complex trauma in the clinical setting, offering insights into supporting survivors and providing safe, effective accompaniment to health services. Through emphasizing harm reduction tips, safe practices, and ethical communication, the Nurse Advocate aims to equip HCPs and other service providers to better serve this population. The presentation will conclude with an open discussion for case consulting, fostering meaningful dialogue on enhancing healthcare services for this affected population.
Presentation Objectives:
• Critically reflect on current learning needs of Toledo, Ohio area health systems in treating persons affected by human trafficking by the end of this presentation
• Discuss common health trends and barriers seen providing direct services to persons from advocate accompaniment to health care visits
• Introduce NAP as an innovative solution to increase access to healthcare services for individuals affected by human trafficking and provide clinical staff relief
The intersection of climate change, migration, and human trafficking presents a complex web of challenges, exacerbated by global racism and systemic vulnerabilities. Climate-induced displacement strains traditional definitions of refugee status, complicating efforts to identify and protect those affected. Factors driving migration are multifaceted, with climate often playing a subtle yet significant role. The ensuing irregular migration creates opportunities for exploitation, with individuals vulnerable to trafficking amid legal and social barriers. Race intersects with these dynamics, shaping perceptions of victimhood and criminality, while policy responses often reinforce racial biases. Despite increasing displacement and trafficking, current responses fall short, necessitating urgent and holistic approaches. Addressing these interconnected issues requires acknowledging race as a central determinant of vulnerability and resilience. Calls for global solidarity emphasize the need for bottom-up initiatives and inclusive decision-making processes. By amplifying the voices of those directly impacted, this presentation advocates for a paradigm shift towards more equitable and effective responses. Failure to address these issues perpetuates injustice and undermines efforts to mitigate the impacts of climate change and human trafficking on vulnerable populations. This session will both educate the audience about the intersections of climate-displacement and trafficking as well as offer attendees specific and manageable strategies for addressing these intertwined forms of oppression at social and individual levels.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss connections between climate-displacement and human trafficking
• Describe the current legislation, policies, and aid available to climate-displaced persons who are victims of trafficking
• Propose recommendations for societal and individual level responses to these intertwined issues
Human trafficking is a crime that preys on vulnerabilities, and although it cuts across age, ethnicity, race, and socioeconomic status, Black girls have an increased vulnerability to sexual exploitation as a result of racism and systematic oppression. Although Black women and girls make up 13% of the U.S. population, they represent 40% of sex trafficking victims and account for 51% of prostitution arrests. Black girls are oversexualized, dehumanized, and often treated as criminals rather than being allowed to exist in environments which provide hope and healing. We each have a shared responsibility to combat human trafficking. In order to prevent trafficking and work to create environments for survivors to thrive, we must address the root causes of trafficking. Through the use of personal testimony, video clips, and group dialogue, the presenter will lead the audience in exploring the experiences of trafficking and sexual exploitation for Black girls and explore the racial roots that contribute to the dehumanization and sexualization of Black girls. Participants will recognize how systematic oppression increases vulnerability to the push/pull factors of human trafficking and evaluate the use of trauma and survivor informed approaches in order to avoid re-traumatization and build resilience.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the role of racism and systemic oppression on vulnerability, victimization, and justice
• Discuss the supply and demand of human trafficking and the sexual objectification of Black girls
• Evaluate the re-traumatization of “rescuing”
• Apply a trauma informed lens in recognizing the need for survivor-centered, culturally responsive approaches to healing
In this session, which is a continuation of a presentation from 2021, we will further explore how providers who want to develop and apply skills to understand DMST’s client-centered narratives and support victims can overcome any hesitancy to engage and begin to build trust, possibly for the first time. Too often, well-meaning care providers participate in a system that re-traumatizes survivors of childhood abuse and interpersonal violence. Providers often misunderstand the presentation of trauma, misattribute behaviors to apathy or defiance, and focus disproportionate attention on the choices of domestic minor sex trafficking (DMST) victims instead of on oppressive social structures and practice standards that recreate their harm. DMST victims’ responses to their trauma, like cursing and insulting, can cause significant discomfort for providers, who respond in ways that echo the autonomy-limiting, dignity-denying patterns DMST survivors have learned to avoid. The presenter will explore how a relationship-based approach is not only an effective way to build trust, but through a relationship-based lens, we can begin to examine the provider’s relationship with their clients and their relationship to the social obstacles that trap clients before, during, and after their exploitation. Specifically, the recommendation here is to lean into one’s discomfort to better understand DMST survivor needs and to apply specific interpretive and communication skills when a survivor’s cursing and trauma-related behaviors escalate. This presentation will assist in helping participants also examine how leaning into discomfort can impact biases and overall self-care in the direct practice in the field.
Presentation Objectives:
• Educate attendees about how DMST survivors and victims present for care, given their exposure to compounding traumas
• Invite attendees to identify their internal biases that can hamper client recovery and understand how this exploration relates to self-care
• Provide specific clinical tools to help providers engage appropriately and effectively with domestic minor sex trafficking survivors and victims
11:15 - 12:15
This presentation offers a compelling narrative intertwining personal experiences as a survivor of sex trafficking with professional insights garnered from working with trafficked and at-risk youth and adults. Through the lens of lived experiences and expertise, the presentation aims to illuminate the vulnerabilities inherent within the demographic of those subjected to trafficking, shedding light on the complex interplay of societal, familial, and systemic factors. With a focus on fostering empathy, understanding, and actionable solutions, Nyki seeks to contribute meaningfully to the discourse at the IHTSJ Conference, advocating for comprehensive approaches to prevention, intervention, and rehabilitation.
Presentation Objectives:
• Share personal experiences as a survivor of sex trafficking to provide insight into the realities faced by victims
• Analyze the vulnerabilities within the demographic of those who are trafficked, drawing upon both personal experiences and professional expertise
• Illuminate the intersectionality of factors contributing to susceptibility to exploitation, including societal inequities, familial discord, and systemic neglect
• Advocate for comprehensive solutions aimed at prevention, intervention, and rehabilitation, informed by both lived experiences and professional insights
Mr. Bandaranayake and Ms. Umrani will present findings from a survey of 150 individuals aged 15-18 across three groups in Sri Lanka's tea plantation areas: children living in plantations and attending school, children living in plantations who dropped out of school to work, and children who moved to cities for labor. The study aimed to understand their experiences and recommend measures to reduce dropout rates and improve safeguarding. Key findings revealed high rates of poverty, violence, abuse, and sexual exploitation. Many children leave school due to lack of resources, low family income, and pressure to work, often facing harsh labor conditions. Root causes identified include the long-term impact of Sri Lanka's colonial history, the 25-year civil war, and continued marginalization of the Tamil community. Plantation schools lack resources and qualified teachers compared to non-plantation government schools. The results underscore the urgent need for intervention. Recommendations include financial assistance for education, school system reform, expanded childcare, improved housing, strict enforcement of child labor laws, and rehabilitation services for abuse victims. A multi-stakeholder approach is needed to implement protective policies and programs. Attendees will gain critical insights into the circumstances faced by children in Sri Lanka's plantations and learn about potential collaborative solutions.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview of the study, including main questions, methodology, and findings
• Describe the key risk factors and root causes contributing to child labor and exploitation in Sri Lanka's tea plantations
• Discuss the implications of the research and propose multi-stakeholder recommendations to address the issues
While the body of research on effective interventions for female adolescents who experience trafficking victimization is growing, much remains unknown about literacy practices in these settings. Previous literature on female adolescents within residential care settings includes examining trafficking risk factors, treatment needs, and service delivery systems. To our knowledge, there is a lack of literature on trauma-informed literacy practices within residential care centers for adolescent victims of human trafficking. Through methodologies of walking and thinking with theory, the researchers explored the public spaces of the residency facility with the seven participants, recording literacy events and the participants’ perceptions. These posthuman and post-qualitative methodologies allowed the researchers to analyze the entanglements of local literacy events, cultural literacy practices, and care within one such facility for female adolescent trafficking victims in the Gulf South. To address the purpose, the researchers asked three research questions: 1) What are the local literacy texts of a trafficked youth residential treatment facility? 2) What are other local literacy events in the facility? and 3) What literacy practices are created by the entanglements of texts, literacy events, and the facility context? Participants included the facility’s seven leaders; data was collected in three phases of walking the common spaces. Findings include literacy practices of belonging, permanence, and remembrance; of spiritual guidance; of educational aspirations; and of individual creativity. This research sheds light into the possibilities for caring literacy practices within an alternative, residential, and educational space for recovering trafficked female adolescents.
Presentation Objectives:
• Highlight the underexplored literacy practices within residential care settings for female adolescent victims of human trafficking
• Shed light on the intricate interplay between literacy events, space, context, and care within these facilities
• Advocate for the implementation of caring literacy practices within alternative, residential, and educational spaces for recovering trafficked female adolescents
• Provide insights into how such literacy practices can contribute to the holistic recovery and empowerment of adolescent survivors
Dr. Cleary and a selection of fellow participant researchers/writers will discuss the preliminary findings from a six-month creative writing project focused on the importance of friendship to social mobility. Fearless Writers was created as a way for university and high school students to work together to disrupt social separation caused by oppressive housing policies known as redlining. Inspired by a Zora Neale Hurston scholar (Rae Chesney) talk at the BGSU Black Issues Conference in spring 2023, the friendship between Hurston and Langston Hughes was used to “activate” the Community Empathy Write (CEW). This community writing project was grounded in history, theory, and both research and writing group method. This project was also inspired by recent groundbreaking research by Raj Chetty and colleagues published in Nature (2022) looking at the importance of friendship to economic mobility. The CEW prompts were informed by participant writers and community stakeholders who were engaged in phases of the writing. Each month, the community of writers were given three prompts, two poem/writing (one Zora, one Langston) and one news story distilling social science research about friendship. The presenters will discuss creative writing as a method to explore collective community experience of friendships. Participants of the conference will have the opportunity to hear a sample of short pieces written by members of the writing research community and learn more about the prompt development. The audience will have the opportunity to write into a prompt, share, and receive strengths-based feedback to get experience with the writing group method. Participants will learn about how the CEW fits into other community writing projects around the country and a movement within medicine nurturing empathy for patient experience called narrative medicine.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview of community-engaged writing and collaborative autoethnography method to collectively explore the connection between friendships and economic mobility from personal experience wisdom
• Describe the benefits of university/public school partnerships in elevating youth narrative about important social justice topics
• Demonstrate how poetry can be used as data and part of legitimate participatory inquiry about social justice concerns
This presentation plunges into the seriousness of child sexual exploitation in America and the criminal justice system. Sherri Jefferson will highlight challenging issues facing Juvenile Urban Sex Trafficking in the U.S. (JUST US) and share recommendations by the African American Juvenile Justice Project (AAJJP) based upon expertise. Participants will learn how the 17Ps (parents, principals, police, prosecutors, etc.) can be impactful in addressing victimization and criminalization and will understand how each can change outcomes. Stakeholders will learn how to effectively help victims of human trafficking and children who are charged as prostitutes. The presentation will educate, engage, equip, and empower the audience to understand facts versus fiction and the obstacles faced by Black families in this space.
Presentation Objectives:
• Dismantle misunderstandings about Black victims of sex trafficking
• Dismantle falsehoods about Black young women and girls
• Discuss opportunities in direct services for this group
• Provide a call to action for a fair criminal record reporting act for victims of sex trafficking whose offenses are beyond prostitution
Access to services to victims of human trafficking in real time has been an ongoing challenge in the U.S. Victims of human trafficking rarely fit simply into the current service provision streams of unsheltered persons or victims of interpersonal or sexual violence. The Arizona community identified the need for a human trafficking specific response, and in February 2023, a statewide human trafficking hotline went live in Arizona. The Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline is a partnership between the Arizona Department of Public Safety and Arizona State University Office of Sex Trafficking Intervention Research with calls going to the Arizona Counter Terrorism Information Center (ACTIC) which is the Arizona Department of Public Safety 911 system. If the caller requests support services, the call is warm transferred to the Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline with trained agents. The Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline agents are led by a Lived Experience Expert with 12 years of experience providing supportive services including crisis response. The second Hotline agent is a native Spanish speaker. The Hotline agents provide immediate support through connections to services, assistance with transportation, emotional support, and assistance with providing basic needs. The Hotline agents can assist callers for up to 12 months of support. During the first year, the Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline received 1,187 calls with 112 unique cases developed with crisis and ongoing services provided. This presentation will describe the process of developing a response protocol including consent, information collection, response protocols, and capacity building activities in the Arizona community.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the process of developing and implementing a statewide human trafficking hotline
• Describe the response protocols developed for the hotline including consent, response, and capacity building
• Discuss the challenges faced and lessons learned during the first year of the Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline
• Describe 4 specific cases and the hotline response activities
Access to services to victims of human trafficking in real time has been an ongoing challenge in the U.S. Victims of human trafficking rarely fit simply into the current service provision streams of unsheltered persons or victims of interpersonal or sexual violence. The Arizona community identified the need for a human trafficking specific response, and in February 2023, a statewide human trafficking hotline went live in Arizona. The Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline is a partnership between the Arizona Department of Public Safety and Arizona State University Office of Sex Trafficking Intervention Research with calls going to the Arizona Counter Terrorism Information Center (ACTIC) which is the Arizona Department of Public Safety 911 system. If the caller requests support services, the call is warm transferred to the Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline with trained agents. The Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline agents are led by a Lived Experience Expert with 12 years of experience providing supportive services including crisis response. The second Hotline agent is a native Spanish speaker. The Hotline agents provide immediate support through connections to services, assistance with transportation, emotional support, and assistance with providing basic needs. The Hotline agents can assist callers for up to 12 months of support. During the first year, the Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline received 1,187 calls with 112 unique cases developed with crisis and ongoing services provided. This presentation will describe the process of developing a response protocol including consent, information collection, response protocols, and capacity building activities in the Arizona community.
Presentation Objectives:
• Discuss the process of developing and implementing a statewide human trafficking hotline
• Describe the response protocols developed for the hotline including consent, response, and capacity building
• Discuss the challenges faced and lessons learned during the first year of the Arizona Human Trafficking Hotline
• Describe 4 specific cases and the hotline response activities
A recent study published in the Journal of Healthcare for the Poor and Underserved leveraged the medico-legal partnerships of HEAL Trafficking and Justice at Work to better understand healthcare utilization among survivors of labor trafficking. Using legal aid organization data, the purpose of this study was to describe the health care utilization and occupational exposures during trafficking among foreign-born people labor trafficked in the U.S. While 4.8 million people are subjected to forced sexual exploitation, up to 14.2 million experience forced labor exploitation. Despite its prevalence, existing research is limited with only 10% of all literature around human trafficking considering labor exploitation. Lack of education and awareness significantly impedes advocacy, prevention, and intervention efforts for this community. Recognizing the clinical touchpoints through which survivors of trafficking interface can equip healthcare professionals to better identify and address the needs of this community. This study is integral in beginning to describe the issue and identify avenues for intervention. Methods for this study included a retrospective analysis of immigration files for health data among 114 labor trafficked individuals. Researchers compiled de-identified narratives from legal documents to highlight potential identifiers of labor trafficked. Data gathered from this study informed a groundbreaking presentation for healthcare providers that reveals healthcare needs, utilization patterns, and intervention opportunities within the medical system and will be shared at this conference.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain why labor trafficking is often overlooked
• Describe the risk factors of labor trafficking
• Report what labor trafficking looks like in the community
• Demonstrate how to respond to victims of labor trafficking
This presentation examines the complex intersections of human trafficking, focusing child sacrifice and ritual abuse globally. These crimes are often fueled by desperation and greed, and exploit individuals and communities. By exploring these interconnected issues, this presentation aims to bring attention to cases often overlooked. We will delve into the realities of trafficking intertwined with the practices of child sacrifice and ritual abuse, providing a comprehensive understanding of the global scope and mechanisms of these crimes. The exploitation of individuals for profit and ritualistic purposes highlights the profound depths of exploitation present in our societies. These practices, shrouded in secrecy and manipulation, leave lasting impacts on their victims. The presentation will investigate documented cases from Africa and North America, analyze the role of the dark web in facilitating these crimes, and share testimonies from a frontline professional from Uganda and a Male Survivor from the United States, who have firsthand experience with these issues. By illuminating these interconnected phenomena, we aim to not only expose these crimes but also to advocate for increased awareness and support for affected individuals, fostering a path towards hope and healing.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explore the intersections of human trafficking, particularly organ and sex trafficking, with child sacrifice and ritual abuse worldwide
• Investigate real-life cases in Africa and North America, backed by dark web analysis, frontline professional testimonies, and survivor accounts
• Raise awareness about these interconnected horrors and advocate for action through shedding light on the crimes and offering hope and healing
12:30 - 1:30
Lunch Networking Sessions
1:45 - 2:45
Covenant House Vancouver has dedicated the past 3 years to learning about best practices for anti-human trafficking and exploring how those practices can be brought home to our youth. This process came from understanding that almost all youth- serving organizations will engage with those at risk, experiencing, and who have survived human trafficking. We have learnt that any youth-serving organization can pivot practice to offer evidence-based supports for anti-human trafficking with 5 key pillars of work. The purpose of the workshop is to educate and galvanize the youth sector including organizations that specifically work with those at risk, victims, and survivors of trafficking along with organizations working with the general youth population. This workshop is informed by an extensive research project that included a literature review, staff focus groups, consultation throughout North America, practice tours, and a thematic analysis. The 5 pillars of increasing organizational capacity to address human trafficking are explored: Staff Awareness, Anti-Human Trafficking Service Model, Resources, Networks, and Youth Awareness and Empowerment. The workshop is designed to engage participants in understanding how anti-human trafficking work can be part of all youth work and how all youth work is either a preventative tool and/or intervention for human trafficking. This workshop is designed to highlight the opportunity of therapeutic alliances developed within youth serving organizations to addressing human trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Engage youth-serving organizations in anti-trafficking work whether they be specialists or not
• Outline evidence-based best practices for anti-trafficking in generalist youth services
• Outline the needs of youth that generalist services can meet for the prevention and intervention of trafficking and exploitation
In this workshop, presenter Brenna Wallace shares her personal journey as a survivor of human trafficking, shedding light on the often-overlooked victims of this heinous crime. Using her own case as an example, Wallace illustrates the signs and indicators of human trafficking, offering insights into how these victims are often hidden in plain sight. Through her harrowing story, Wallace will highlight the importance of recognizing the signs of human trafficking and provide recommendations on how individuals can help these victims escape their abusers and move towards healing. She will also discuss the need for stronger legislation and support systems to protect and empower survivors of human trafficking. Additionally, Wallace delves into the insidious tactics of coercion used by traffickers to control their victims, showing how even the strongest individuals can become trapped in a cycle of abuse. This presentation serves as a powerful call to action, urging attendees to stand up against human trafficking and support those who have been silenced and forgotten.
Presentation Objectives:
• Raise awareness about the prevalence of human trafficking and the hidden nature of its victims, using the personal story of Brenna Wallace as a lens to understand the complexities of this crime
• Educate attendees on how to identify signs of human trafficking and provide actionable recommendations on how they can support and assist victims in seeking help and breaking free from their captors
• Advocate for stronger legislative measures to combat human trafficking and provide better support for survivors emphasizing the need for a comprehensive and coordinated response to this global epidemic
• Illustrate the different forms of coercion used by traffickers to control their victims, shining a light on the psychological and physical manipulation tactics employed
Beyond offering human trafficking prevention education to youth, rigorous evaluation of programming that considers the voices of recipients is much needed to advance safety of teens across the U.S. 168 high school aged youth at a school in a Midwest School District were offered 4.5 hours (six 45-minute sessions) of programming focused on preventing human trafficking. Students’ feedback on the program was solicited following each session, and 462 written forms were thematically analyzed to determine 1) overall reception to the program, 2) grouping categories most reflected upon, 3) self-reported/perceived impact of participating, and 4) negative emotions (materials making one feel upset/unsafe) elicited. Data from pre/post surveys, and program fidelity forms were integrated to generate a rich overview of programming context, participants, and effect. The findings of the program evaluation suggest most students had positive reception, gained positive effects from participating, and with few instances of students reporting feeling upset or unsafe. Feedback primarily reflected upon program educators, program structure/layout, and materials/activities. Themes of programming impact most centered on gained skills and knowledge. Based upon student reflections, researchers curated recommendations related to generating positive human trafficking prevention programming reception and impact with 9th-12th grade students. Collectively, youth responses indicated the need for programming to be interactive, include information related to current events/focus on local sources, and be delivered by educators willing to integrate compassion, authenticity, and at times humor about a difficult topic often shrouded in a culture of silence.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explore findings of thematic analysis of the feedback generated from high school aged youth participants of a human trafficking prevention education program
• Discuss successes and areas of improvement needed for positive reception to curriculum
• Highlight lessons learned and future directions for generating community based participatory research in the field of human trafficking
Transportation plays a key role in combating human trafficking. This session presents the findings from the National Outreach Survey for Transportation (NOST) focused on forced labor, addressing the significant data gap regarding the intersection of human trafficking and transportation. NOST, the first-ever U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) Combating Human Trafficking in Transportation Impact Award-winning proposal, is a comprehensive survey primarily for multiple modes of transportation. The survey aimed to identify what is and is not working on the frontlines of counter-human trafficking efforts and document unresolved challenges and recommendations from a total of 3,896 respondents from 1) transportation personnel, 2) victim service providers, and 3) trafficking survivors. The NOST also sought to supply data that may contribute to recommendations to improve counter-trafficking efforts. Among 173 respondents working in various state DOT construction units, only 26% feel slightly or very confident (19% and 7%, respectively) about identifying labor trafficking in their work environment. Participating transportation workers confirm specific training topics that may help to identify forced labor proximate to the work environment or within the community, transportation-related venues, and events. Respondents from multiple transport modes also provide valuable suggestions on how personnel and industry leaders can help combat human trafficking in supply chains. For the primarily U.S.-based transportation respondents, the most suggested strategy for encouraging companies to use products free from forced labor in their supply chains was high penalties (1,229 respondents), followed by loss of tax benefits (850 respondents) (total n = 1,766). Organizations can utilize these results for their anti-trafficking plans in consultation with the local community and broader anti-trafficking stakeholders in the transportation industry.
Presentation Objectives:
• Present frontline input on human trafficking, including the survivor and service provider perspectives, on the intersection of human trafficking and transportation, including the supply chains associated with the sector
• Provide specific recommendations for the transportation industry
This presentation addresses the phenomenon of spiritual trafficking within religious institutions through identifying, analyzing, and defining the trend. The research will be in light of first-hand lived experiences as the researcher recounts their own experience of being groomed, trafficked, and subsequently re-exploited by religious communities. The research conducted is a Directed Content Analysis by the presenter of existing research, trends, and standards of the concepts of spiritual abuse, human trafficking, and the intersection of these concepts. The initial research question was, “Is spiritual trafficking a definable term” and the research provides an overview of the current research while identifying gaps in this data. The findings of the research assert there is indeed a category of spiritual trafficking that has been observed and more research should be dedicated to further expand it. This presentation serves as a poignant backdrop for the exploration of spiritual trafficking, a term coined to encompass the manipulation and coercion of individuals within religious contexts. Spiritual trafficking can overlap with sex or labor trafficking; yet can be categorized as its own experience, much like spiritual abuse (which can overlap with sexual or domestic violence but ultimately can be categorized separately with its own harmful abuses that are spiritual in nature). Drawing parallels with the better-known concept of spiritual abuse, the presenter elucidates how spiritual trafficking aligns with the definitions and tactics of traditional trafficking, involving elements of force, fraud, coercion, manipulation, and control.
Presentation Objectives:
• Create a working definition of “spiritual trafficking” through research and first-hand experience and differentiate it from “spiritual abuse”
• Identify the dynamics, tactics, and ways that spiritual trafficking translates into four distinct variants: grooming, passive exploitation, active exploitation, and re-exploitation
• Utilize first-hand experience to give tangible examples for the audience to identify these theories in practice
• Create a call-to-action for faith-based communities and beyond to address this concern
While sex trafficking and porn have both been defined as forms of sexual violence, rooted in a system of gender inequality, what is often overlooked is the way these two industries are culturally and economically linked. The first part of this presentation will explore how porn acts as both a method of recruitment into trafficking, and a major driver of demand. Drawing from empirical research and testimonies from porn performers, trafficked women, and sex buyers, we argue that as long as we have a multi-billion-dollar porn industry, we will always have sex trafficking. By unpacking this symbiotic relationship between porn and trafficking, we can develop a more nuanced theory and practice to abolish all forms of sexual violence. The second part of this presentation will highlight the most popular social media platforms accessed by young people today, exposing how social media has been hijacked by the porn industry. We will provide examples of how social media platforms are fueling sexual exploitation and prostitution, from the exchange of sexual currency in Live Streams, to the grooming and recruitment of young people into prostitution and sex trafficking. The harmful and dangerous effects of the collusion of these industries will be discussed. Finally, we will conclude with how Culture Reframed, through a public health approach, assists parents and professionals who work with young people in navigating the treacherous terrain of social media, pornography, prostitution, and trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explain how the pornography and sex trafficking industries are culturally and economically linked
• Explain how pornography acts as both a method of recruitment into trafficking and a major driver of demand
• Explain how social media platforms fuel sexual exploitation and prostitution and the harms this causes
• Discuss strategies for safe, gentle conversations to engage young people in talking about hypersexualized social media, sexual exploitation, and violence
Child labor and forced labor are subject to widespread international sanctions, leading perpetrators to hide the sources of these goods. As a result, some honest and ethical companies may unknowingly purchase goods produced by exploited labor. The U.S. Bureau of International Labor Affairs has published a list of goods by country produced by child labor for forced labor. In this Matched Case Control Study, individual countries with the most goods from trafficked labor are each matched to the most similar country where goods from child and forced labor are relatively rare. Economic, government, social, education, and other data are mined to find consistent differences between high- and low-prevalence countries. The objective of the study is to identify risk factors for child and forced labor to support further investigation and identification of perpetrators and as an aid to companies seeking to avoid inadvertent purchase of goods produced in this way. In this analysis, leading risk factors are found to center around economic disadvantages for the families of the victims, including unemployment and economic opportunity, unavailability of credit, government corruption, poor education, and social and political upheaval. Supported by this analysis, conference attendees will be able to identify countries and goods where child and forced labor is hidden in supply chains and help avoid them, target their own efforts towards these areas, and promote use of the list as a tool for addressing exploited labor in supply chains.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the list of goods by country produced by child labor for forced labor created by the U.S. Labor Department's Bureau of International Labor Affairs and how it can be used to better understand child and forced labor
• Provide details of how a Matched Case Control study is conducted and applications in human trafficking research
• Identify and explain prominent risk factors for child labor and forced labor
This presentation offers insight into the ways community systems can overlook signs of human trafficking, resulting in the proliferation of vulnerabilities and victimization. This session will be led by an expert in the field who will draw from their unique lived experiences to provide an understanding of this complex issue, following a 29-year journey marked by trafficking and missed signs. By delving into the intricate dynamics and lasting impacts of systemic oversight, participants will gain an understanding of the distinct challenges presented to survivors with experiences of being “missed” by service providers across spectrums. This comprehensive presentation has been crafted for victim service providers and law enforcement, caregivers of youth in the foster care system, adoptive parents, advocates, and other professionals. The presenter will discuss their survivor story, including how a series of systems did not identify or intervene in the trafficking situation. The session will end the presenter walking attendees through the process of strengthening systems to better identify human trafficking in their communities. For example, how to be invested in our communities, hold space for people within the systems we serve, and how to be aware of common signs within our field.
Presentation Objectives:
• Consider how to integrate the survivor case study into their best practices
• Assist attendees to ask the right questions and build rapport through trauma informed application
• Reinforce an appreciation for thorough human trafficking 101 trainings and assign where those trainings may be lacking in their communities
Without the ability to report crimes without being arrested for prostitution, sex workers and sex trafficking survivors are easy victims. Burns’ 2015 thesis action research on the lived experiences and policy recommendations of people in Alaska's sex trade uncovered the experiences of Alaskan sex workers and sex trafficking survivors in trying to report serious crimes to the police and led to Alaska passing the U.S.'s first immunity in reporting laws for sex workers. After the law was passed, Alaskan sex workers and sex trafficking survivors reported crimes like child pornography, sexual abuse of a minor, and information about an unsolved murder. One sex trafficking case Burns helped report illustrated the need for sex work clients to also be afforded immunity in reporting. Most recently in Alaska, a brave sex worker stole a phone containing videos of a horrific murder and reported the serial killer Brian Steven Smith to police. Rhode Island currently has two immunity bills (one of which Burns helped draft), which illustrate the importance of local context and critical thinking in crafting effective immunity laws. In Rhode Island and nationally, an ongoing qualitative survey of sex workers and sex trafficking survivors allows criminalized victims and witnesses a safe way to share their stories with lawmakers. Currently, seven states have immunity from prostitution laws for people reporting crimes, and there is quite a bit of variety in the laws. This presentation will explain the elements of effective immunity laws and the public education that has to happen after immunity laws are passed.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the importance of action research in achieving relevant policy change for sex workers and sex trafficking survivors
• Convey the important elements of an effective immunity bill and the importance of bills being rooted in an understanding of local contexts
• Use examples and storytelling to help attendees understand the importance of immunity bills in fighting sex trafficking and other heinous crimes against sex workers and sex trafficking survivors
3:15 - 4:15
The issue of sex trafficking has long been a narrative that has involved women and girls. We now know that males are victimized by sexual exploitation in large numbers and it’s important to eliminate the gender bias and homophobia that males face as a result of their victimization. This presentation will address the various risk factors that males experience that result in their exploitation. The presentation will address how males identify their experience, the adverse childhood experiences that define their level of trauma/complex trauma, services needed to support recovery, policy recommendations for service providers from a multidisciplinary perspective, and how to develop programs organizationally specific to male victims/survivors.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe the risk factors that lead to the sexual exploitation of males
• Discuss how males identify the categories of victimization
• Describe the services needed for victims/survivors to support recovery
• Provide various policy recommendations for organizations/providers to support programs for male victims/survivors
Little research exists on previous educational attainment, present educational status, and future educational aspirations of adolescent survivors of sex trafficking. Even though education is highlighted as a “factor needed for success” for survivors, there is a paucity of information. Twelve current residents were included in this study; data came from intake surveys on past education, current educational achievement data, and interviews on current and future educational aspirations. Research questions included: 1) What were their past educational experiences? 2) What are their educational needs? 3) What are their small and big goals? and 4) What is their vision of success? The findings focus on the risk factors, current educational successes and challenges, and tensions in their future goal setting. Upon intake, most residents had multiple educational risk factors, and several residents also exhibited disruptive behaviors in their schooling history. Implications for practice include a need for targeted remedial education and individualized learning plans to help these adolescents catch up academically. Moreover, the presence of disruptive behaviors highlights the necessity of incorporating behavioral and psychological support within educational programs. Trauma-informed educational practices and mental health services could be essential components in helping these students engage positively with their education. By amplifying the voices and experiences of these residents, social workers, educators, and researchers need to prioritize the transformative power of educational attainment and aspirations in future studies of adolescent trafficking survivors and in developing successful residential programs.
Presentation Objectives:
• Provide an overview of the study, including main questions, methodology, and findings
• Identify educational risk factors, successes, and challenges survivors face
• Understand the importance of prioritizing educational attainment and aspirations in survivors’ recovery
• Describe the implications and recommendations based on the research for residential care settings
In 1975, Vicksburg, Michigan was a sleepy quiet little farming community. People thought that the Masonic Organization and Jehovah Witness church were helping families in the little community. But they did not know children were sexually abused by both organizations. Many children were forced to do sexual acts and drugs were put in the food to make them sleep. Rita O'Brien considers herself to be a fearless fighter in taking the next steps to get justice. At first, she started by learning more about what trafficking was. After educating others for 8 years and seeing the patterns that her dad displayed, Rita wanted to do more. Rita had to live a double life that no one understood. Rita went to school during the day, but endured the horrors that no child should have to endure. The day her dad allowed over 30 men to sexually assault her and another boy in her teens was the last. She wanted this horrific life to end. Later in life, she heard about Kalamazoo Area Anti-Human Trafficking Coalition and learned to speak to educate her community. Rita is now teaching police recruits at Kalamazoo Valley Community College a 4-hour training on human trafficking. She is also trying to find a way to get laws passed to have Michigan require that all children aged 5 and older be taught what trafficking is and how to get help. Now, she speaks under Michigan State Police with Michigan Commission on Law Enforcement Standards (MCOLES) to educate Law Enforcement on what needs to change and what has to be done. Rita will share her story to shed light on the abuse and trafficking that happened and what a predator looks like. She also wants people to know about properly educating police recruits so that change can happen community wide.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe what a predator looks like
• Discuss what made situations in life difficult
• Discuss the survivor’s life experience
• Discuss what how to best work in the community
Research studies traditionally use a top-down approach that excludes community members from decision-making processes. In contrast, community-based participatory research is a collaborative approach focused on dismantling traditional inequities by conducting research that engages, shares power with, and benefits communities of interest. Therefore, this community-engaged approach can help mitigate risk of misinterpretation and misrepresentation of findings. This study sought to use a community-based participatory research approach to investigate the life histories of adults who experienced commercial sexual exploitation (CSE) prior to the age 11. Together, the lead researcher and lived experience experts, part of a community advisory board, will share how they partnered in conducting this study. Research participants will provide their perceptions of the research process and perspectives on how this approach exceeded their expectations. This presentation will provide real world examples of how community-engaged research approaches can assuage ethical concerns and reduce risk of harm and re-traumatization when investigating issues related to CSE. This presentation will identify the bidirectional benefits of community-engaged research and address ways that collaborators can simultaneously care for their physical and emotional selves. Further, this presentation will elucidate the lessons learned through this process and offer suggestions on how to make community-engaged research viable, mutually beneficial, and sustainable.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe characteristics of community based participatory research and how it relates to research on CSE
• Identify the role and value of integrating lived experience into research processes
• Analyze the benefits of using community based participatory research in CSE research and the impact it can have on researchers and community members
The intertwined issues of human trafficking, reproductive rights, and abortion ignite intense debates due to their ethical complexities. Human trafficking, a severe violation of human rights, involves exploiting individuals through coercion or deception. This includes sexual exploitation and forced labor. Reproductive rights, centered on bodily autonomy, emphasize individuals' rights to make choices about contraception, pregnancy, and abortion. Access to safe abortion services is vital for exercising these rights. The nexus of human trafficking and reproductive rights presents ethical dilemmas. Trafficking victims may struggle to access reproductive healthcare due to coercion or lack of resources. Some argue that enabling access to abortion for these victims protects their autonomy and prevents further exploitation. Conversely, opponents cite moral objections, including religious beliefs and concerns about the rights of the unborn, advocating against abortion promotion even for trafficking survivors. The presenter will outline this complex issue and talk about why it’s important to dialogue and understand the perspectives of both sides of this critical issue.
Presentation Objectives:
• Explore the issues of human trafficking and reproductive rights, including abortion
• Outline the debates occurring between those who support and do not support abortion
Human trafficking is a public health issue that requires a trauma-informed, survivor-focused response from all health care providers. There is evidence related to the healthcare needs of trafficking survivors, but there is still limited research and insight into the best approaches for the treatment of psychological trauma experienced by trafficking victims. The trauma experienced within this patient population is chronic and complex. This workshop explores best practices in a phased approach used to treat trauma and trauma-related symptoms of trafficking victims. In phase 2, participants will be introduced to the Flash Technique modified for therapy with survivors of human trafficking. The Flash Technique can help prepare the survivor for Phase 3 trauma treatment because it allows them to process traumatic memories with minimum or no feelings of distress. This training includes an overview of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing Therapy (EMDR) techniques specifically for use with survivors of human trafficking. Please note, EMDR and other techniques should not be used without advanced, multi-hour training and relevant certifications. Participants will be provided additional training resources offered by the Emancipation Nation Network. Participant engagement through case studies related to recovery stories will be shared. A special clinical impact will be emphasized throughout the training related to the trainer’s personal and clinical experience working with other survivors of trafficking.
Presentation Objectives:
• Identify three trauma-related symptoms of human trafficking victims
• Discuss three evidence-based practices for the treatment of trauma and trauma-related symptoms
• Detail the Flash Technique and EMDR and discuss how it is specific for treating trauma-related symptoms with human trafficking victims
• Explain the recovery process for survivors of human trafficking
The Department of Justice's Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section (MLARS) oversees the Department’s Asset Forfeiture Program (Program). One of the Program’s primary goals is to recover assets that may be used to compensate victims when authorized under federal law. Since 2002, MLARS has returned nearly $12 billion to hundreds of thousands of victims with forfeited assets in cases supported by MLARS. MLARS also operates an Anti-Human Trafficking Initiative with a mission to investigate and prosecute targets engaged in sex trafficking, forced labor, human smuggling, and child exploitation offenses, with a specific focus on how these offenders and criminal organizations finance their operations and launder their illicit proceeds. This presentation will focus on the types of cases where the Department can compensate victims with forfeited assets, along with information for victim advocates who are directly assisting victims of federal crimes. The presentation will address different categories of victims and schemes, with a focus on human trafficking, along with discussing the documentation and information that will need to be submitted to the Department.
Presentation Objectives:
• Identify differences between forfeiture and restitution
• Present scenarios when federal asset forfeiture, including civil forfeiture, may be available
• Explain how various categories of victims, specifically human trafficking victims, may be treated under current regulations
• Discuss strategies for compensating victims with losses that fall outside of the regulations
Florida is estimated to have the third highest amount of human trafficking in the United States. Victim identification and a misunderstanding of the crime impede the arrest process, while downstream orientation and prosecutorial discretion affect the judicial process. Through a conceptual framework of cultural blinders, prosecutorial decision-making, and victim-centered investigations, this study analyzed the prioritization of Florida's human trafficking investigations, whether trafficking convictions reflect original arrest charges, and the current issues with Florida's current legal definition of human trafficking. A mixed-methods approach using state and federal convictions and the National Human Trafficking Hotline accompanied by semi-structured interviews with law enforcement, prosecutors, civil and non-profit attorneys, and victim advocates are used to test the hypotheses of this project. The research finds that sex trafficking is the main focus of human trafficking investigations; prosecutors rely on victims' testimonies, which influence plea deals, and the current stipulation of trafficking laws places high burdens on the victims' testimonies, influencing revictimization. It is recommended that further research be conducted on states that provide victim protection during the deposition and testimony stages of the trial to determine if the prosecution has different outcomes. Furthermore, more law enforcement officers should be interviewed to determine why labor trafficking is not investigated in Florida.
Presentation Objectives:
• Describe an overview of Florida's human trafficking judicial system, study methodology, and preliminary findings
• Provide recommendations for judicial reform in Florida to assist victims and survivors better
4:30 - 5:00
Wrap-Up Session